[Spoilers MAIN] Are the Starks all slowly turning into villains?
One of the themes of this series is that power corrupts. Yes, the world is shades of gray and there are very few true villains, but if we consider villainy in this series to be the corruption of power, we can see this being a path for a large number of characters. Of course we have the obvious examples like Joffrey and Cersei, and strong hints that Daenerys and Tyrion are rocketing toward that end, but I think more overlooked are the signs that George seems to also be slowly corrupting the Starks with positions or abilities that are too much of a temptation to abuse. George has noted that "the only thing worth writing about is the human heart in conflict with itself." In this series he seems to do this by giving characters an opportunity to gain what they understandably want, but then perverting that goal in such a way that they (and we) recognize that it shouldn't be pursued in the manner they're choosing.
Catelyn, of course, died and was resurrected as Lady Stoneheart. She's hanging innocent men and children, obsessed with revenge for the Red Wedding, even against those that had nothing to do with it. She's seen as a leader, and it's clear the men underneath her fear to go against her, which is an essential requirement for a leader to become abusive. She has basically already become a villain, because while we understand her desire for revenge, her actions are far beyond what we would consider acceptable in the pursuit of that aim.
Arya has gone overseas to essentially learn how to become a Faceless Man, but she's still also deeply bent on revenge. In the show she slaughters the Freys, which - while not book canon - at least hints that George was planning for her to become a full-fledged assassin. Additionally, she's a warg that has a connection with a direwolf that is leading a vicious pack that is causing problems for the Riverlands. She has a lot of potential to abuse her powers, without a moral compass guiding her in the process. We can recognize that while she deserves justice, she's taking a very dangerous moral path to getting it.
Bran might be the sneakiest, because not enough people are acknowledging his repeated raping of Hodor. Yes, rape - he's using Hodor's body for his own benefit, without Hodor's desire for it, in a way that is clearly psychologically destructive. As a noble, Bran has been trained to ignore the humanity of those beneath them, seeing them as tools for his own ends. And now he's with the three-eyed crow, who also sees little compunction with using the ability to skinchange. Like Arya, that gives him a really powerful gift without anyone ever having guided him on using it in a moral way. There's really good reason to suspect that he's going to be the eventual king after all of this is over, but the question is: under what terms? If he has the ability to just take over the mind of someone in a position to become king, would he do that?
Jon assumed the mantle of leadership at the Wall, and was killed for his decisions as commander. That death makes things hard to predict, but we do know that he won't come back the same. If/when he's resurrected, what will he be like? What sort of vengeance will he take against those that murdered him? Will he pursue the same path of revenge that his mother did - since death has technically relieved him of his vows - or will he become something different?
Sansa is the one that has the most likely positive outcome, with the fewest signs of falling. She also has a much more secure moral base. However, she is being mentored by one of the most power-hungry and evil men in the realm (Littlefinger), and has a path to returning to leadership, as she did in the show. How much will her journey change her?
Lastly we have Rickon. Who the hell knows what's going to happen with that kid - we don't know what his motivations or intentions are. Skagos is allegedly a hard land where people practice cannibalism (is that a myth or real?). We do know there are three noble houses there (Crowl, Magnar, and Stane), so they're not completely anarchic barbarians - maybe they decide to use him for their own aims or something. But there really hasn't been enough to glean where George is going with his arc.
So what do you all think - do any of them (if not all) actually fall in that way?