RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/asoiaf • … • u/Cosmic815

(Spoilers Main) Renly was valid

Okay, so I am a show only watcher and this question is for both show watchers and book readers.

I am curious why Renly didn't use the fact that Stanis worships the lord of light as validation for him skipping the line of succession?

I am pretty sure that the king of Westeros has been crowned in the light of the seven since the conquest, right? So surely Stanis throwing that away is an actually valid reason for him to no longer be eligible.

Look at the English monarchy for example, if you are not a COE Christian then you cannot be king.

I just feel like it would make more sense for him to use this as a reason, the small folk clearly love the faith of the seven so even if he didn't believe it surely it would help him rally even more support.

Maybe there's something in the books that explains why he doesn't do this, I'd love to know.

EDIT: I just want to clarify, I understand that Renly was claiming the right of conquest and all of that. But my question is why not also use the conversion of Stanis to a foreign religion and his rejection of the main religion of Westeros as another form of validation? It would certainly get the small folk on his side and could have potentially helped him gain assistance from the faith in the future if needed.

Kin slaying is seen as a super serious issue in Westeros so killing his elder brother without a valid reason just seems like something he'd obviously try to find a way justify.

— 0