(Spoilers Extended) Something that bugs me about Rhaegar and Lyanna
Haven't been on this sub in a long time, so forgive me if this topic has already been covered.
So we know that Rhaegar and Lyanna ran off together and had Jon. We know that Robert's Rebellion broke out and Rickard and Brandon Stark died in the Red Keep. We know that Arthur Dayne died at the Tower of Joy as Ned and Howland Reed tried to get Lyanna, and he discovers the truth of the matter.
This is where my issue lies. Rhaegar is implied to have loved Lyanna, so much so that he broke his vow to his wife and ran off with her. And Lyanna would have been equally smitten with the young prince for her to throw everything to the wind and run off with the crown prince while betrothed to Robert. But then Rickard and Brandon are executed by Aerys and war breaks out.
Before Rhaegar goes off to fight at the Trident, he leaves Arthur Dayne, Oswell Whent, and Gerold Hightower to guard Lyanna. Now, for all anyone in the Seven Kingdoms knows, Rhaegar kidnapped her. That's what Rickard and Brandon thought when they went to King's Landing, it's what Robert and Jon Arryn thought when they went to war, and it's definitely what Ned thought when he arrived at the Tower of Joy.
Rhaegar has to know this, and he has to know that Ned, provided that he survived the war, would come looking for her. Ned has no idea if she's okay and just wants her back. And Rhaegar leaves Arthur Dayne, the greatest swordsman in the Seven Kingdoms, to make sure no one can get to her, including what little is left of her family. (Arthur doesn't get a pass on this either, but this post isn't about him)
Was Rhaegar really willing to have all of Lyanna's family, save Benjen, wiped out? I can't wrap my head around the idea that Rhaegar would have thought Lyanna would have been okay with this.
Sorry if this has all been covered before and I'm just digging up old shit, but I just started thumbing through my copies of the books and this has just been sticking at me. Anyone else got thoughts like this or am I completely missing something here?