RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/billsimmons • … • u/Mr_Saxobeat94

The Celtics are performing better with Brown off the court. It’s not noise. This has pretty much always been the case.

To be more specific: they’re outscoring opponents by 13 points per 100 possessions over the 562 minutes he’s missed, the equivalent of almost 12 full NBA games. Remove garbage time and it’s still double digits. He’s got the worst on-off in the starting lineup (I’ll address the “contextsplaining” later)**

This is not new, btw. Brown has been in the league for 10 years, has missed about a season’s worth of games, and has averaged 31mpg when he’s played, meaning there’s a rather gargantuan sample of off minutes. Within that sample, the Celtics have outscored their opponents by 7 points/100, 1.3 points better than when he plays and have a higher win percentage when he’s in street clothes. **They are 84-35 in the 119 games he’s missed in his career, an absolutely staggering 71% win rate.** This is buoyed by going 29-4 since the start of ‘23-‘24 (12-0 in ‘24, 15-4 last year, 2-0 this year), but even if you wanna throw those numbers out…they were 55-31 in his missed games before that, too.

**Now, on to dispelling the selective “context”-wielders: yes, everyone already knows that raw on-off and even missed game data is flawed. But no collinear adjustment (I.e anything factoring in teammate/opponent quality and staggering, as pbp stats do) changes this picture too severely. All of his advanced stats range from pedestrian-to-very-good…literally all of them, *no matter the methodology* (pbp/hybrid are much different than box score-based advanced stats) converge to say Jaylen Brown is not quite as good as advertised. The most favourable ones are DARKO and EPM, which have him as a Top 20-25 player (pointing this out to not be accused of cherry-picking, as most others leave him out of the Top 50, some out of the Top 100, some worse than that). And indeed, he’s a very good basketball player

But…”carrying the Celtics,” “Alpha Dog on a championship team,” “MVP candidate”….no. These are all massive bridges too far.

— 0