Did we play Food Chain Magnate completely wrong or the game is designed for pricing wars?
The short version...Our Food Chain Magnate sessions always end up with price wars, is it how the game's supposed to be played? There are 17 houses in total, each house can have a total of 3 foods/drinks, which makes it 17\*3=51 "demands", there are 6 chefs and 3 zeppelins can be in play which makes the production value 8\*3\*2 + 5\*2\*3 (assuming each zeppelin picks up from 5 sources) = 78. It's way more than the demand..... and it doesn't even include other cooks/operators/trucks
And the longer version...
A bit of background, we are a group of 4, we play quite a lot of medium/heavy (usually between 3.5 and 4.2 scale) board games (most have lots of player interaction be it direct or indirect)
We started with Food Chain Magnate a while ago and managed to play it 4 times in total.
1st play was amazing, 2nd play was a bit repetitive because everyone seems to have to follow a certain path. 3rd play was with milestones and it was meh nothing special, we don't like milestones. 4th play was with 5 players and it was terribly boring because of the price wars :(
Not sure if we are missing anything. In our last play, there were 3 burger chefs, 3 pizza chefs and 3 zeppelins in play which makes the production rocket high. There were also 2 radios and 2 planes and several mail boxes advertising stuff. Not to mention all the houses were built. The price war was not as bad as everyone goes to 0 but only like -5$ or -7$. The problem I had was that if you don't join the price war, you have nothing left. I had 1 burger chef, 1 pizza chef and 1 zeppelin but there were still nothing left for me. One guy with -5$ discount, got like 180$ in one go.
I mean of course I can join the price war but I find it kinda boring that everyone has to do the same thing to win. I can see few counters for the discount strategy like luxury manager + lots of advertisement to rise the demand to a point that there might be still something left for you. But if you are the only one trying to do that, it would take too long, and by that time the game is almost over :( Another way is using Waitress, but without the milestones (we don't like milestones btw), 3$ per turn is nothing....
I did some math, with the total number of houses (I remember 17 or something), if we advertise like crazy, each house will have 3 demands (max is 3 I think), so total is 17 \* 3 foods/drinks. With 5 players, all chefs/zeppelin in play, the amount of production is 8\*3\*2 + 5\*2\*3 (assuming each zeppelin picks up from 5 sources) = 78, and that doesn't take into account other cooks/operators/trucks which can even raise the amount of production higher. Even if I turtle in 1 corner and use Luxury manager it's still not effective as going full discount. Even if I make like 10$ after paying, I still win because other players are making nothing and still have to pay...
P/s: sorry for the long post and broken English as it's not my native language
\----- Apparently, we played it wrong, a house with garden should have 5 demand instead of 3. That actually changed a lot of things. Also, the milestones are not optional