C8 Z06 driving impression from a Ferrari 458 owner
One of my friends recently took delivery of his Z06 convertible and took me for a ride and also let me take it for a spin. I drove my 458 to his place so we would be able to drive them back to back to compare. Please keep in mind that this was only a spirited drive around some back roads and not a test of the cars on track or anywhere near their (or our) limits. With that being said, here are some of my thoughts, for those that are interested in what an internet stranger has to say about the subject:
My biggest takeaway was that I was surprised by how much more exciting the Ferrari was to drive. On paper, the C8 is objectively the better car; it's faster but it certainly doesn't feel like it. Driving back to back, the Ferrari feels like the faster car from behind the wheel. The Ferrari is a more visceral drive--it's louder in the cabin, the ride is more firm, and the steering is of course, very quick and sharp. The ride on the Corvette is very comfortable, but the result is that it feels soft in even the track setting relative to the 458. There is very little feedback through either the steering wheel or the chassis, and the result is that the car feels very isolated from the road. If you put a blindfold on me (and ear plugs), I would've guessed I was riding in a Lexus. I suppose, to a certain extent, that's what much of their buying demographic wants.
If you look at the dimensions, the Z06 is about 6 inches longer, and it certainly looks like a big car in person. I think the wide body looks great, and the Z06 rear is a big improvement over the Stingray to me, but there's no getting around the fact that the car is BIG. It feels bigger and heavier than the 458 from behind the wheel as well. That changes when you're inside, though, because the Corvette feels cramped inside relative to the Ferrari. The seats are higher off the ground in the Corvette, the side belt lines are higher, and the central tunnel between the driver and passenger really cuts into the interior space. The Ferrari is obviously much more open without that. The wall of buttons further makes the interior cramped, though you only really notice that from the passenger seat. While it feels cramped by comparison, I liked the interior from the driver's seat, and being much newer, the Corvette has a lot of nice tech available.
Regarding the sound, they both sound great, though we both agreed that the Ferrari sounds just a little better. Part of that is probably that there's less sound insulation in the 458, and the tone is a little better. The 458 can drone a bit around 3,000 RPMs with the valves open, and the Z06 does as well, but it does so for longer in the rev range--at least with the windows up. The Corvette has more pops and burbles though, which I liked.
Granted, the car was pretty new, but the overall build quality looked really good and the car felt very solid, but there were a couple of GM type things: the gap between the door trim and the dashboard was much bigger on the passenger side versus the driver's side, and there was a piece of passenger window weather stripping that was pinched up big enough for me to fit my pinky in to. That should be easy enough to fix. Weirdly, there's a pretty gross smell that seems to be coming from the exhaust area, and apparently people are already talking about it on the Corvette forums. Hopefully it goes away with time. You couldn't smell it inside the car, thankfully (even with the top down).
Overall, I think it's a great package for the price--it's comfortable, fast, and looks and sounds great--but it feels much more GT car than sports car to me. I'm sure that will be fine for many buyers, but the 458 is definitely the the more exciting car to drive. Others will surely disagree, and that's great--everyone has different opinions!
tl;dr: Despite the similarities on paper, they are very different driving experiences. The Corvette is a great car that's objectively faster, but feels slower behind the wheel and is too isolated from the road. It feels like a GT car versus a sports car by comparison.