RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/changemyview • … • u/LucidMetal

CMV: America will Transition into Corporatism Over the Next Few Years

Corporatism is a system of economic organization where rather than government regulating industry and industry merely lobbying the government for favorable treatment, heads of industry are directly involved in regulating industry to pursue their interests.

For those unfamiliar corporatism is an economic system where industry groups (aka syndicates or “corporations” – but not in the contemporary meaning) negotiate government policy with the head(s) of state in a top-down manner. This is distinct from the current mostly laissez faire system where government interference is fairly limited and industry groups simply lobby heads of state and the heads of state take their interests into consideration among the other lobbies (bottom-up).

What this means is that we will see a lot of protectionist policy, reduction in environmental regulation, reduction in labor rights, increases in cronyism and corruption, and expertise on fiscal, monetary, and general economic policy being not just ignored but actively shunned by the admin.

Many argue we already live in a corporatocracy, but although it is undeniable that corporate interests are disproportionately represented I don’t think control is that direct. Antitrust is still used routinely.

Corporatism is distinct from corporatocracy in that it is not corporations specifically running the government but rather representatives of corporate groups advocating for the interests of their industries (and I think that pretty much everyone across the political spectrum would agree that means themselves).

The new DOGE commission (apparently tweens will be running the government for the next few years) is the first step and sets a pretty strong precedent that heads of industry will be driving regulatory policy. I predict that the commission will be lauded as "successful" and then will be incorporated into government more directly with Congressional approval (or maybe it turns out it's not even necessary since they're already in the admin).

I think corporatism is a bad idea so trying to convince me it’s not so bad or is actually good is probably not a fruitful line of argument. Saying “we don’t know what will happen” will also not work. That’s not the point.

What would work best against my argument is to show how there will be a failure to implement corporatism (give me hope) or how the definition won’t be accurate for our impending neo-feudalist hellscape so semantics are fine. If you do want to argue the definition is accurate you should both propose an alternative descriptor of what will happen and explain why it is more accurate.

EDIT: The most common comment by far was something like "we're already there" and I didn't actually exclude that as a possible line of reasoning even though I don't find it particularly interesting. In order to avoid moving the goalposts, if you can find one regulatory agency in relatively recent history that was headed by someone who was previously a high ranking official in an industry that agency regulated you will get a delta.

— 0