CMV: Training AI on human-created work is ethical and reasonable. It is not theft or plagiarism.
Before LLMs, it was extremely obvious to me that a future AI will need to learn in the same way humans learn in order to mimic (perhaps surpass) human behavior and understanding. Unless you are simply opposed to new technology, this is something we must accept *and* encourage if we are to improve AI capabilities.
Making it illegal, or thinking it's immoral, to train on human-generated datasets is just a technophobic step that holds technology back.
My main argument is: **If it's moral for a human to learn from books, media, and the public internet, then it is moral for an LLM to also do so. If it's stealing for an LLM to do so, then it is stealing when humans learn and later make money from the skills they gained training on human-generated data**.
Counterarguments I see coming:
1. **LLMs are not human, it's totally different**:
This is not really a good argument. The logic is the same, and nothing about being human, per se, makes it more moral than a machine learning from public data or data the LLM's owner paid for.
For the most part, this is the only argument people can come up with, in my experience, and it's more of a cop-out to shut down conversation, and there is never any elaboration.
This is Change **My** View, and "LLMs are not human" is incredibly unconvincing to me as an argument, even if I agree with the fact that LLMs are not human.
2. **AI companies pirate and actually steal data in order to train their models**:
OK, this I agree with! We both agree that, for copyrighted work, not paying for it is immoral. **If**, however, no piracy is used in the training of the model, then it is definitely moral.
3. **AI can regurgitate copyrighted work and it can hurt authors/artists**:
Again, we agree here. If the AI does not meaningfully include safeguards against spitting out copyrighted work, then that would not be OK. I am talking about an AI that does implement these safeguards.
4. **I just don't think AI should exist**:
OK... Irrelevant to the topic at hand. Downvote and move on if you want.
---
I am open to changing my mind on this. But, even before the AI hype, it has always been clear to me that training on human-generated data is both necessary and OK in order to push the technology forward.