RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/changemyview • … • u/Big_Sea_5912

CMV: George H.W. Bush is a severely underrated president

To put it all out there: I think George HW Bush is the greatest president of all time and one of the greatest statesmen in history. Though he is often rated in the upper half of presidents, I dont think he is appreciated enough given his insane resume and the limited time he had in office.

My claim rests on three arguments:

1) H.W. Bush's character and competence was unimpeachable and this reflected in his presidency.

2) H.W. had by far the greatest foreign policy success of any statesman in history. While lauded, these still do not get enough credit.

3) H.W. had among the best domestic achievements of any president that went unappreciated in his time.

**H.W.'s character**/**qualifications:** H.W. is perhaps the only man to be overqualified for the presidency. His career started with him becoming the youngest aviator in the Navy's history. He had come from a very privileged background and could have easily avoided the draft, but was compelled to join anyways. He was awarded the distinguished flying cross and dodged death over 58 combat missions. In spite of this[, he consistently refused to call himself a hero or draw attention to his military ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3KTkfqk-OGw&t=5s)achievements see it as his duty. Later, H.W. would become a successful oilman before entering politics. He would serve as the US special envoy to China, Ambassador to the UN, director of the CIA, and of course vice president. Through it all, he remained a devoted family man.[ His letter to his daughter ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZN_Ey0dUyE)that had passed away and to [bill clinton](https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/101724) stick out to me as particular great examples that demonstrate the man he was.

**H.W.'s foreign policy brilliance:** The man was the greatest diplomat in history and it showed. He had replaced the Narco dictator Noriega with an allied democracy in Panama, ensuring stability and protecting US interests in a geostrategically vital region without virtually any casualties. He managed the dissolution of the USSR masterfully, inviting Russia to participate in the community of nations and bringing Germany into NATO, ensuring continental stability in a time where that was far less certain. His crowning achievement, however, is being the only statesmen in history to stabilize the gulf. H.W. assembled the largest coalition in history, representing 75% of the worlds population at the time to include the USSR and Saddam's fellow Baathists in Syria, to thwart Saddam's attempts at conquering the eastern oil rich provinces of Saudi Arabia and repel his invasion of Kuwait. In doing so, he created a stable and rich gulf ally and would strengthen our relationship with Saudi Arabia. More crucially, he prevented the greatest geopolitical catastrophe since WW2. Had Saddam invaded Saudi as intended, every other regional actor would be forced into the conflict and international actors would be drawn in by Iraq's new monopolization of Oil resources. The result would be carnage worse than GWOT middle eastern infighting. By bearing down a massive and unstoppable force, and providing a swift exit with limited objectives (not marching on Baghdad), H.W. solved the Saddam problem without inviting further carnage. It was a near impossible tightrope to walk but he did it.

**H.W.'s Domestic achievements**: H.W. signed and championed the American disability act which stands as one of the most progressive pieces of legislation since the civil rights act. Famously proclaiming 'let the shameful walls of exclusion finally come tumbling down'. On the economic front, he imposed needed fiscal discipline in a time of reckless spending through the Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990 which was massively politically costly for him but helped enabled the growth and surpluses of the Clinton years (along with the High Performance Computing Act of 1991). People will point to the recession during his time, but the reality is the US was due for a recession and its often more instructive to look at what happened AFTER a president left office than what happened during their time in office.

Again, this was all in one term. Its hard to argue any president achieved more than HW Bush did in one term. Frankly, few presidents acheived what he did in two terms. That without causing much if any long term harm. Given this, I think H.W. Bush deserves to be rated much higher - among the best presidents and statesmen in history.

— 0