RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/changemyview • … • u/Remarkable-Ad3191

CMV: Apple and Google Maps didn't cave to Trump on "Lake America," and switching to MapQuest to punish them is aimed at the wrong target

I see many people blaming Google and Apple for caving or sucking up to Trump on the name change. Many going as far as to delete both apps, boycott the entire companies, and switch to MapQuest and DuckDuckGo instead. I think there's a lot of misunderstanding about what actually happened here.

Firstly, Apple and Google have used the same policy for years. Inside each country, they show whatever that country's own government naming database says. Everywhere else, show both. That's why Google shows "Sea of Japan" in Tokyo, "East Sea" in Seoul, why "Persian Gulf" and "Arabian Gulf" both appear depending on where you're standing, why the Crimea border looks different from Moscow than from Kyiv.

I think this rule's purpose is to take company out of the judgment seat. Nobody at Google decides who's right about Kashmir. They point at the database and say "talk to your government."

Now if you're thinking "Well MapQuest did it, why can't Google and Apple?"

MapQuest is an ad-tech-owned app with no meaningful presence in China, Iran, Russia, or anywhere else with a naming fight. Nobody is going to ban them. So yes, they took a stance. It cost them nothing and made them a fortune in free press. Good for them. That's a marketing decision available to a company with nothing to lose.

Google and Apple are on every phone on Earth. If they override a government database once, every other government with a naming dispute lines up, asking for the same favor. Picture the phone call the next morning: Beijing says "you overrode US for Canada, so now label Taiwan a province of China or your iPhone factories have a problem." Moscow wants Crimea drawn as Russian. Tehran wants "Arabian Gulf" gone. And now Apple and Google have no principled way to say no, because they've already shown the database is negotiable if you push hard enough.

If Apple or Google were able to adopt a different naming standard, one that keeps Lake Ontario on US phones, applies uniformly to every disputed name on Earth, and doesn't require an employee at Apple or Google to decide which government is right, then perhaps my mind could be changed. But right now I can't think of one.

— 0