CMV: Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) services can genuinely help struggling individuals avoid the worst traps of poverty
\[For the purposes of this post, I'm mainly referring to platforms like Klarna that offer regularly spaced interest-free installments over a certain interval, like Klarna's Pay in 4. But historically BNPL companies like Affirm and Klarna have offered even longer 6-12 month 0% APR deals for select merchants and products like mattresses, electronics, apparel, and fitness equipment.
The vast majority of these BNPL providers perform 'soft credit checks' that do not damage credit score, and they have historically been incredibly generous to low-credit individuals; in fact, [CFPB data](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/archive/newsroom/cfpb-research-reveals-heavy-buy-now-pay-later-use-among-borrowers-with-high-credit-balances-and-multiple-pay-in-four-loans/) reveals that BNPL lenders have approved 78% of loan applications from subprime or deep subprime consumers, meaning that struggling individuals are not locked out.\]
Now, I'm sure we're all familiar with the Boots theory of socioeconomic unfairness, which essentially states that a lack of access to upfront liquidity forces poorer individuals to make subpar purchases that require frequent replacements, ultimately draining more money in the long term than a higher-quality product would have.
This is where BNPL comes in: providers like Klarna let individuals split payments into installments, delaying the full payment and requiring only a fraction of the expense upfront. The implications are staggering: full purchases of high-quality goods can now be delayed until the averted replacement expenses pay for them.
Consider a simplified example: a consumer chooses between a cheap, low-quality $100 pair of boots that last 6 months and a high-end $200 pair that last several years. Ordinarily, that individual might have only $100 on hand, forcing them to buy the inferior option. But with BNPL, they might be able to pay in 4 $50 installments over the course of a year. The first installment is not only within their means but even *cheaper* than the $100 option, allowing them to save or reallocate. By the time the consumer reaches the last two installments, they are paying $100 in an alternative world for a new pair of boots to replace the shoddy original pair, which is now in tatters. But in the BNPL world, they can pay for the last two installments with *the share of their paycheck that would have otherwise been sacrificed for a replacement*. BNPL has just extended their liquidity far enough that they can pay for quality now, circumventing later costs.
Another underappreciated perk of interest-free BNPL programs is that, from an economic perspective, they are a figurative and literal free lunch for the consumer. Time value of money dictates that money now matters more than money later (for a whole host of reasons that are readily available online). The lack of interest means that this added economic value is essentially given for free. Instead of paying for a $5000 mattress now, you can pay a mere $1250 and pop the remaining $3750 in the market or a risk-free asset, drawing out only what you need to pay each installment. By the end of the interval, you will *definitionally* have more money than if you had paid the full cost upfront. For all these reasons, I'd require a lot to be convinced that BNPL programs are *not* a win-win proposition.
tl;dr BNPL providers let struggling individuals play around with and stretch their incomes for no added accounting cost, giving them the berth to avoid the cyclic traps of low upfront liquidity and to build a foundation of quality, lasting goods.