RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/changemyview • … • u/Falernum

CMV: we should weaken airplane cockpit doors going forward.

After 9/11, we overreacted in a variety of ways, many of them far more consequential than this. One of our overreactions was an international push to strengthen cockpit doors and make them unassailable, so that passengers would be unable to hijack airplanes any more. At that time, the possibility of a pilot intentionally crashing a plane was considered extremely unlikely and at any rate unsurvivable.

And we've since seen a massive decrease in hijackings by passengers. Possibly related to this, but probably mostly because passengers and crew used to expect to be inconvenienced but now expect to die if a hijacker takes over.

But a few times, this locked cockpit has proven deadly. MH370 is probably such an example, although it's hard to prove for sure. The Germanwings murder-suicide involved a copilot locking the pilot out of the cockpit before crashing the plane. LAM Mozambique 470 involved a pilot locking the copilout out of the cockpit before crashing the plane. And of course today such an attempt failed because one of the pilots heroically managed to keep the door open after being stabbed by the other.

Breaching the cockpit door should neither be trivial nor impossible. We should have a door that delays such breaches and makes them very obvious, such as a wooden door that can be broken by body slams, or a door lock that disables after 45 seconds of sustained pulling, and alarms the entire time.

By making a delay, we prevent rushes on the cockpit from succeeding but also make pilot-initiated attacks harder. Obviously nothing is perfect, but in the instances where there is some time, we should reasonably assume that the majority of people on a plane don't want to die and thus that a melee should be permitted to occur.

— 0