RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/changemyview • … • u/TruckerMark

CMV: EV rated receptacles are a scam.

With the rise of EVs, home charging has been the talk of the community. This is a north america focused issue so I will address north american code and NEMA outlet standards. I use a standard NEMA 14-50 connector, wired to code ⅘with a 40 amp rated EVSE.

My local suppliers are selling EV rated receptacles for sometimes in excess of 10x the price of a normal outlet.

A few points of clarity and fact statements

1. NEMA receptacles have an amperage rating for non continuous loads. Continuous loads must be at 80%. EVs are a continuous load and therefore should be operated at 80% of the rating.

2. NEMA plugs are only rated for 100 cycles, but the evse generally remains plugged in and only the more robust J1772 connector is used.

3. EV loads are no different than other continuous loads at the same amperage and voltage.

4.Worn plugs, poor connections, unceritifed appliances and other improper installation or code violations present a similar danger if the load was not an EV.

Therefore EV rated plug manufacturers are creating a situation where numerous contradictory situations are occuring.

Either the electrical codes and standards for NEMA plugs are unsafe and require immediate review and recall actions(given both ev rated and regular nema plugs are sold by the same manufacturer they admit their own products are substandard) OR EV rated receptacles are just a means of extracting high margins from people wealthy enough to own an EV.

So please change my view on how both the above statements are both untrue or my statement of facts is incorrect.

Edit: if someone can provide evidence the UL listing is failing to adequately rate the plugs, i will award a delta.

Edit 2: I have supplied a delta on the basis that the ev rated receptacles are much more difficult to install incorrectly and therefore safer for careless installers. I prefer to save 75$ and spend a few extra minutes to install UL listed hardware correctly.

Edit 3: the NEC and the UL have demonstrated that they are incompetent and should be held accountable for approving unsafe devices.

— 0