RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/classicwow • … • u/goriq_

What do you think the honor system revamp will look like?

With more information on the upcoming honor system revamp for classic era servers, what do you think the new honor system will look like?

Before classic was released in 2019, many people asked for changes to the honor system, which is understandable, but I always hoped it would stay the way it was so I could experience the original honor system (I started playing in TBC back in the day). After making it to rank 10 in classic, I got to experience the pros and cons of the system myself and I have to say I'm in favor of making #somechanges to it now.

**Arguable pros of the original honor system** The original system encouraged me to keep participating in BGs all the time, because I had to if I wanted to rank up! As a reward driven player, later iterations of the PvP system felt less motivating to participate in because once I had all the honor gear, there was no immediate short to mid term reward left. Put differently, the honor system had a consistent engagement level while engagement levels in later iterations have a drop-off point. In the original honor system, every point of honor counts. Due to the extreme nature of the grind in the original system, players were also more likely to form communities and premades to rank up together.

**Arguable cons of the original honor system** The grind in the original honor system is obscene. I started ranking at the end of classic and finished my rank 10 grind a week before the ranking system was disabled for TBC. I don't have any exact records but it was somewhere around at least 5-6h of BGs per day for roughly two months. It was often miserable. If I hadn't been unemployed at the time (living the stereotype), I would have had no chance to make it to rank 10. And you don't even get any really good rewards until rank 10. So for any regular adult or reasonable person, participating in the honor system to reach higher ranks or rewards is not motivating. The return on investment isn't there. Due to the nature of the system, the flipside of the community-generating effect it has are "honor mafias". At the higher ranks, the spots for people that can rank up is limited. Due to that, people had to engage in honor tracking to make sure those that were "allowed" to rank up that week could get their rank up. If you overcapped, it would result in a punishment. Another factor that is not directly caused by the honor system itself but exacerbated by it are premades. Playing in a non-premade against a premade is not fun. And in classic, losing a BG usually meant receiving little to no honor, which is what you need to rank up. Losing a game, as a result, is practically a waste of time. It can be argued that it makes teamplay, communication, etc. all the more important because you have to try and win as many games as you can. Ultimately, however, the pressure to win is disproportional to how insanely long the grind is.

**Possible solutions** There are two main solutions I have in mind for changing the honor system as it is.

1. Replacing it with later iterations of the honor system It's easy to just say "let's implement honor points or BG marks and let players farm the PvP gear that way like they did from TBC onward". This would be a simple but lazy way to change the honor system since it goes against the spirit of the original system. Now, correct me on this if I'm wrong, but based on what I know about SoM (which had faster ranking), people just ranked to get powerful gear fast and easy, invalidating the dungeon grind for prebis or maybe even some raid items. So this teaches us that PvP rewards in classic cannot be too accessible. One way to do this would be to award players with honor in a similar fashion to arena points from TBC onward. However this would require a way to rank players in a more granular fashion akin to an arena rating system which would be difficult to implement for classic. Also, solutions of this kind would create a situation in which anyone that participates in the system would get their items eventually, which might not be desirable for the long term health of the community. 2. Adjusting the existing honor system A more sensible approach would be to adjust the existing honor system in more subtle ways to make it possible to keep its original spirit intact while also not making PvP gear too easy to earn. One way might be to adjust how many rank points players are rewarded during each reset. However, Blizzard would have to be cautious here not to recreate the same scenario we saw on SoM. Another solution to consider is to keep the ranking system the way it was but remove the rank point decay of 20% that happens during each reset. This way the grind would still be long and players would be able to take it at their own speed. However, players would still run into a ceiling created by how much time they can spend ranking every week. And ultimately, many players would just get their rank 14 eventually which might oversaturate the community with PvP geared players.

These are the two main paths I have in mind for possible changes to the ranking system. I wonder if Blizzard might have any crazy ideas in mind like implementing the rated BG system from Cata. That way, classic PvP could receive an additional layer of skill and premades could be removed from regular BGs. Rewards could also be split with blue PvP gear being available for honor and HWL/GM gear being locked behind rated BG ratings.

What do you guys think the honor system should look like and what do you think the honor system is likely to look like after the changes?

— 0