RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/consciousness • … • u/wwants

Is a perfect copy of me any less me than the me of the next moment?

I’m trying to work through this idea and would love feedback and critique on how I’m viewing it.

The usual copy puzzle goes like this: someone makes a perfect copy of you, memories and all, and the question is which one is really you. The way I’ve come to see it, the you of this moment doesn’t carry forward into the next one at all, whether through a copy machine or through any normal instance of time. Each moment there’s a new instance, built out of everything that came before it in a way that feels continuous, but it’s a distinct instance. Sleep isn’t special and neither is a teleporter. A perfect copy is just the case where one moment has two successors instead of one.

If that’s right, a couple of things follow. The copy isn’t me from my perspective and I’m not it from its perspective, and once we split neither of us can get at what the other is experiencing now. But we both have an equal claim on the shared past, so there’s no deeper fact about which one is the original.

By a moment I mean the shortest span that can be experienced at all, below which you can’t tell one moment from the next. I don’t know how long that is, and from what I’ve read nobody agrees, or even agrees that experience comes in discrete steps. I don’t think the view depends on the number, but maybe it does and I’m missing why.

So where’s the hole in this? Is it fair to describe future iterations of yourself as being as foreign as a copy would be? I’d especially like to hear from anyone who thinks continuity is doing more work than I’m giving it credit for.

— 0