RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/cowboys • … • u/Guac_Bowl_Cuck

[OC] The most telling Dak Prescott stat that helps sum up his issues.

I know we're on a 3 game winning streak and everyone is feeling good so it may not be the best time on this sub to be negative; but with the talks of resigning Dak and everyone appearing to be all for it I feel like I should try to put his flaws into perspective.

​

First let's start with some positivity and get into some common misconceptions about Dak:

​

1. Dak is inaccurate. I really don't get where this one comes from. Does he miss throws? Yes. But so does every QB. Based on the throws he attempts to hit compared to the league average, his completion percentage is actually 1.4% higher than expected. This is good for 13th in the NFL. So, not terrible. (Link to all these stats will be provided at the end of the write up)

​

2. Dak only throws the ball once receivers are open. Again, this is false. 19.9% of Dak's throws are into tight coverage. This is the third highest in the NFL.

​

Now, onto the negative. The stat that inspired me to write this up is actually a combination of 2 stats. There's the common viewpoint that Dak doesn't throw the ball downfield so I decided to look into that. In terms of intended air yards (average distance of all pass attempts without YAC) he is 23rd in the NFL with 7.6 IAY. Derek Carr is last with 6.3. Jameis Winston is first with 10.9. That's not great but there are guys like Roethlisberger and Brees that are actually below him in this category. So statistically speaking, he throws the ball downfield more than those guys. On the surface that doesn't look so bad.

​

Then I looked at average time to throw. Dak is 3rd in the NFL at an average of 2.96 seconds to throw. Drew Brees is the fastest at 2.56 seconds. Josh Allen is the most at 3.18.

​

So I grouped some people up. Of all 12 QBs with an average of 2.75 seconds and above to throw, only 3 of them have less than 8 IAY. Those three are Dak Prescott, Blake Bortles, and Brock Osweiller. The 9 that have above 8 IAY are Baker Mayfield, Aaron Rodgers, Josh Allen, Jared Goff, Deshaun Watson, Sam Darnold, Pat Mahomes, Alex Smith, and Russell Wilson.

​

Of all 18 QBs that are below 8 IAY, only 3 take more than 2.75 seconds to throw. Those three are, once again, Dak Prescott, Brock Osweiller, and Blake Bortles. The other 15 QBs are Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger, Drew Brees, Nick Mullens, Carson Wentz, Andrew Luck, Ryan Tannehill, Eli Manning, Cam Newton, Kirk Cousins, Matthew Stafford, CJ Beathard, Marcus Mariota, and Case Keenum.

​

So what does this tell me? Well when you're in a group with Bortles and Osweiller and no one else, that's usually not a good thing. But it tells me that Dak's number 1 problem as a QB is his inability to read a defense. It's not just the fact that he holds on to the ball too long, and it isn't just the fact that he's afraid to throw it down field. Some QBs hold on to the ball because they're 7 step drop players and they like to throw it deep (guys like Mahomes and Goff) then there are QBs that check it down quite a bit but make such fast reads that they're never getting sacked and they're constantly moving the chains (Brees and Brady). But then there are guys like Dak, Brock, and Bortles. Guys that are holding onto the ball like a 7 step drop QB but checking it down like a west coast QB. Dak takes too long to read a defense and stares down one receiver until it's too late. Witten pretty much said as much during the Monay night game when he called Dak a "one read QB."

​

So, before we go wanting to resign him for money anywhere from 18-25 million. Let's remember the company he shares. The only other two guys in the same category as Dak are both riding the bench this week. I know it's easy to get hyped up during a win streak. But hopefully this helped put things into perspective.

​

[https://nextgenstats.nfl.com/stats/passing/2018/all#average-intended-yards](https://nextgenstats.nfl.com/stats/passing/2018/all#average-intended-yards)

​

TL;DR: Dak's ratio of time to throw vs how far his passes go are rivaled only by Brock Osweiller and Blake Bortles. This is indicative of his inability to make quick reads.

— 0