RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/cycling • … • u/mikekchar

I rode an e-bike for the first time today. My thoughts...

I went for a trip to Kanazawa (I live in Japan) and met a friend. He offered to show me around the city by bike. Normally I'd bring my bike, but the route I took had a lot of transfers on the train and I didn't really fancy carrying it. I rented a bicycle from the city rent-a-bike program (less than $10 for the whole day, but they only have 14 bikes, so you have to get there right at 9 am). It turned out to be an ebike.

My first impression was: "Holy crap this thing moves". I was barely using the weight of my leg to push the bedal down and I could feel the G-forces. It took me a while to figure out what's going on.

Japanese e-bikes are 100% assist up to a certain speed (I think somewhere around 12 k/h) and then it decreases in assist as you speed up. I think it cuts off at 20-25 km/h. The problem is that electric motors have basically a flat torque curve with respect to RPM. If you start off in 1st gear, it gives you all the torgue of the motor -- which is a *lot*. The damn thing takes off like a rocket and you basically have to control it with the brakes.

As a regular cyclist (around 150-200 km/week typically), this was a super weird feeling. A little flick of my foot and I'm suddenly getting more torque that I get when I'm stomping hard on the pedals. As you speed up, it gradually gets more and more like a bicycle, but at slow speeds, it's simply a foot actuated motocycle.

Anyway, we rode around for a good 8 hours and since we were in the city, I never got out of zone 1. We hit a few grades around 4% and just flew effortlessly up them. This was just not cycling as I know it.

I have mixed feelings because as a tourist, it was probably the most amazing way to travel around. Complete and absolute freedom and virtually no effort for the entire day. I'm kind of sold on this as the best way to tour a city.

However, if you are not very careful, it is extremely easy to be an absolute menace. I was surprised at how hard it was to avoid riding like a moron. Especially in crowded spaces where there were a lot of pedestrians, I'd put my foot down on the pedal thinking I could just ride several meeters behind people and suddenly I'm breathing down their necks.

I think a big problem is the design of the bike I had. It should absolutely scale the torque by speed and increase torque slowly. Ideally it should follow my torque and give me help when I'm really stomping on the pedals while stay quiet when I'm doing nothing. However, that basically means putting a power meter on these bikes and the city bikes are not in that price category.

I've had a pretty relaxed view of e-bike regulations before, but I think that there should be a complete re-think of regulations for what's allowed on these things. I think if you are riding at maybe 75% of the max speed of these things, it's fine, but the accelleration possible at the low end is just stupid. As I said, it's just not a bicycle at that point and I don't think it should be classed as one.

I'm also really changing my mind about most e-bikes wrt to exercise. Unless there is some way for the bike to limit torque based on your power output, it's just essentially a motorcycle at low speeds and a bad bicycle at high speeds. It also doesn't seem to transition nicely (or at least this cheap on didn't). I don't doubt there are much better ebikes that can serve you well for exercise, but I suspect they are way out of the price range of most people.

— 0