Order of the Lycan Blood Hunter is a problem
Over the last few days, I have already gone into more detail about the Summoner, the Blood Hunter, and briefly touched on the Blood Domain.
At this point, I want to highlight another problem that exists within the design of the Blood Hunter.
The new Order of the Lycan is, overall, better designed than the previous version because it is no longer dependent on the one transformation that made the subclass far, far, far, far, far too strong, especially at level 1.
However, it is still a major problem.
In the following, I will explain why, and I will also present a build that is among the strongest damage dealers in the current game from an offensive perspective.
# The Lycan Blood Hunter is actually one of the strongest subclasses in the game right now.
Or rather, it would be if the Blood Domain weren't currently in such a terrible state. The subclass itself is strong. Very strong, in fact.
Admittedly, the original version was even stronger, especially in Tier 1, because it provided guaranteed access to a transformation that was already overpowered on its own. That's no longer the case, since the transformation has been removed. That said, it's worth noting that, in principle, it can still be combined with the Lycan Blood Hunter if the GM allows it.
The bonuses the Lycan Blood Hunter receives may not be particularly flashy or mechanically complex, but they are incredibly powerful.
# The absurd strength of the Subclass
The extra damage, scaling from 1d4 to 1d6 to 1d8, is actually the less important part. What really matters is the 1d4, 1d6, and 1d8 bonus to all Action Rolls, not just attacks. That is enormously powerful.
As the class currently stands, the **Lycan Blood Hunter is better at climbing, sneaking, Knowledge Rolls, and virtually every other Action Roll.** And in combat, adding 1d4, 1d6, or 1d8 to every attack roll makes an enormous difference. The Lycan Blood Hunter gets that benefit almost for free.
**Right now, I wouldn't prioritize Strength for a Lycan Blood Hunter. I'd invest in Agility instead, focus primarily on the Bone Domain, and build around high Evasion.**
I'd also largely ignore the Blood Domain, aside from a handful of cards that are still exceptionally strong (looking at you, Viscious Form), including a few of the new additions. But there are very, very few of them.
# The strongest build for the Order of the Lycan
Start as a Blood Hunter with the Order of the Lycan, then multiclass into Warrior at level 5 and take Call of the Slayer. This lets you avoid gaining Hope when you roll with Hope. Instead, you gain a Slayer Die, which means you can maintain your Hybrid Form for much, much longer without any real downside.
On top of that, starting at level 5 you gain access to the lower-level Blade Domain cards, which includes some incredibly strong options such as Whirlwind, Not Good Enough, Scramble, and others.
Then, at level 8, you return to the Lycan subclass and take its Specialization.
If, **and this is a very big "IF"**, your GM also allows your character to become an actual werewolf through the transformation, the bonuses stack. You would then gain **1d10 plus 1d6 to every attack and every damage roll, along with 1d6 to every Action Roll.**
That's strong. In fact, it's extremely, extremely strong.
# In short
I have no idea why the designers of the Blood Hunter thought it was a good idea to make the action roll bonus apply to all action rolls rather than just attacks. Maybe this is simply a wording issue, but as written, that is currently how it works.
I also don't understand why this bonus scales. The damage bonus could theoretically scale, and that would still be relatively fine. But even a 1d4 bonus to all attacks alone is already an incredibly strong benefit.
For comparison, the Warrior's Hope feature requires spending 3 Hope to gain a +1 bonus to a single attack (Edit: to all attacks!). The Blade Touch level 7 card grants +2 to attack rolls if you have four Blade cards in your loadout.
A 1d4 bonus to all attacks is already extremely powerful. Having it scale all the way up to 1d8 does not make sense to me. In fact, it suggests that whoever currently designed the Blood Hunter has little understanding of how Adversary difficulties function in Daggerheart.
With all of that said, I want to emphasize once again that the Blood Hunter still has significant problems, primarily because of the Blood Domain. But that is a separate discussion...