Quick song by song review after one listen.
I’ve been a fan of DGD since DBM and wanted to weigh my thoughts based on a single listen through. Granted, I’ve already heard the singles, but I relistened to those to get an idea of how they flowed within the album.
**Animal surgery:** wild grit from Andrew. Some interesting Coheed vibes. Always a plus for me. 9/10
**McGuffy’s:** stereotypical DGD song. Follows the standard formula to a t. Safe choice for the first single. 8/10
**Robot Rebirth:** this one’s interesting to me. It starts off feeling like it was written for Royal Coda, and then transitions to a Tilian era DGD song. Has a lot of compelling parts but doesn’t exactly flow. 7/10
**Conqueror Worm:** I dig the groove. I liked the intro but I feel like those vocals (not sure who they are) but they kinda got stale by the second or third time they appeared. 7/10
**Trap Door:** Another safe single that follows the DGD formula. Jon’s vocals sound great. Dude never stops impressing. Catchy as fuck too. 8/10
**Strawberry:** I fucking love when Jon sings like this. Idk who was singing during the bridge, but it was a great addition. Definitely an early favorite of mine. 9/10
**Space Cow:** Let me preface this by saying I’m a huge George Clinton fan, and I was completely perplexed and intrigued when I heard they were collaborating with him. With that said, I feel like they were kind of looking for an excuse, or a way to wedge him in to a song once they got confirmation that he would work with them. It just doesn’t vibe the way I thought it would. I think they released this as a single out of pure excitement. Bad choice IMO. I’m going to address the mix as a whole at the end, but this song sounds extra muddy. 3/10
**All The Way Down:** Another safe single. Singable and catchy. Definitely has some Chino Moreno vibes in the chorus which is kinda different, but I think it works with the background chant. 8/10
**A Shoulder To Cry On:** Holy SOAD vibes. This is so fucking cool. I’m loving the slow arpeggios on the guitar, and Matt is doing some work back there. I can totally see this not being everyone’s vibe, but this is such a cool song for me. I think it ends a bit weaker, but I’m going to be coming back to this quite a bit. 9/10
**Superstition:** It’s fine. Sounds like another Tilian song. I don’t want that to come off as a bad thing. DGD has always needed a one album transition period to adapt to their vocalists, and they had a whole album written for Tilian. It’d be a shame to see it all go to waste. Choruses also feel just so empty. 4/10
**Stickler:** Matt is really solidifying his spot as one of the best drummers in the game. Again with these wild unclean vocals. So damn good. Starting to think that’s Andrew, which holy shit. That might not be everyone’s cup of tea, but I’m so down for it. Getting some occasional Korn vibes here too, in the intro and the bridge/breakdown. Such a cool vibe here. 8.5/10
**Yikes:** I feel like this song has the potential to go hard in subsequent listens. Most of the song has like a war march feel to it. The second half has some intrigue in it too, but I think this song especially is going to take a few extra listens to u pack. 5/10
**Chaos:** This song kind of feels like the culmination of this album, and gives a path forward. As I’ve noted in previous song impression, I think this album has a lot of what I call “dad metal” vibes, like SOAD, Korn, Deftones, Staind, Disturbed, etc. I feel like this song is a bit of a blend of everything they’ve explored on this album. I feel like Andrew is utilized very well in this song too, and actually in the front of the mix where he belongs. I think for a finale, it’s a bit underwhelming, as DGD has always had bangers to close out albums, but I can safely give this a 6/10.
**Final thoughts:** I HATE when bands don’t just commit to their new members in the mix. The Chili Peppers did this after Frusciante left after Stadium. They got a new guitarist and basically deleted him from the mix.
I feel like in quite a few songs, Andrew is completely buried, and while I was only listening in my AirPods Pro 2s, I kinda feel the same about the bass too. On top of that, the remaining instruments didn’t sound like they had their own place within the mix with the exception of the drums, which were mixed extremely well in my opinion, if not a little loud in some parts. The rest sounded extremely muddy. Gave me some OG Acceptance Speech vibes.
Overall, I was expecting a transitional album, and having gone in to this with that expectation, I’m not disappointed at all. I really liked the experimenting they did, and the heavier vibes they played around with.
For me, Mothership remains the gold standard, and I don’t think that’s this is anywhere close to it. With that said, this probably falls right in the middle of DGD’s catalog for me, perhaps slightly higher. An easy 7/10 for me on first listen, with a lot of potential to rise with subsequent listens.