How I'd make Byakuya Togami work as the protagonist of Trigger Happy Havoc.
**Warning: Rambling.**
I had this idea while watching a video about who would make for a good protagonist if the current protagonist wasn't.
I always liked the idea of Byakuya as a protagonist because of how different to the typical everyday man he'd be. He's smart, but also an asshole, judgemental, and extremely rude. The full opposite of the average Danganronpa protagonist.
Of course, he already has the basics, such as having a working brain, which can be a tall ask in Danganronpa, but that's not enough to be a good protagonist.
What would his arc be?
Two: a main one and a secondary one.
The main one is basically the thing he goes through in >!Chapter 4: Learning that logic alone cannot win cases, as humans are inherently emotional and illogical, and the more he tries to deny that part of a person—and even of himself—the more he'll be left behind by people who are able to empathize, such as Kyoko.!<
Two: Being a leader rather than a dictator: Byakuya is a character that naturally takes control of a group once he becomes a part of it, but I think it'd be cool if he went on a character arc where he learned to be a less authoritarian while still competent leader, sort of like, ironically, >!Twogami !<does.
Lastly, of course, there's being less of a dick.
Now, who'd be his Antagonist and support?
Let's start with support:
There are a few choices.
**Toko** is an obvious one. She'd love to be it, but IMO, she doesn't bring enough to the table in a killing game (Specially pre UDG) to take this role.
**Makoto** is also an option too, but outside the role of the protagonist, Makoto is a fairly boring character. I'd prefer another.
**Celestia** is an interesting choice. Having the two more antagonistic and assholish characters cooperating would be interesting. Celestia already hold him in high regards so I'm sure Byakuya would tolerate her over others.
**Kyoko**: Likely the most powerful duo, but unlikely to work together since Byakuya would see someone smarter than him as a subconscious threat.
But my main pick: **Aoi Asahina.**
Now, this seems like an odd pick. No offense to my GOAT, but Aoi isn't precisely recognized for being smart, but that's precisely what would make her a great support.
Aoi is the epitome of emotion in THH, while Byakuya is the epitome of logic. They're polar opposites, and that's what makes their dynamic so good.
Aoi would be less of a "Smart support that gives you smart clues you wouldn't think of" and more of a Kaito Momota type of support. She complements Byakuya's faults due to his lack of empathy early on.
They would probably hate each other at first, but I imagine their relationship getting better over time. Byakuya would have to learn to appreciate or maybe even quietly admire someone for something that isn’t their intelligence or position.
They'd learn from each other. Byakuya would learn to empathize and appreciate emotions and the inherent vulnerability that comes with being human, while Aoi may learn to be a little more cold-headed and less gullible. I think they could make for a great duo.
Who'd be the antagonist? There'd be two, although one is not the antagonist in the regular Danganronpa sense.
1. **Kyoko** (In the sense that she opposes the protagonist): She's the "Rival" type of antagonist. In this case, Byakuya would essentially be salty that Kyoko keeps being smarter than him and he's unable to truly match her intelligence. She's not the antagonist in the sense of being evil, but in the sense that she is the person Byakuya is aiming to overcome (And indirectly learning from her)
2. **Celestia**: Celestia would be the more classic Danganronpa antagonist. Sometimes siding with Byakuya, sometimes going against him. She'd be a social manipulator that, while at Byakuya's level of intelligence, is socially in a better position within the group. She'd likely be the person who commits the big murder in chapter 5.
She may be able to partially or totally manipulate Byakuya himself, either by stroking his ego or simply by trying to convince him to escape, or maybe she'll manipulate Byakuya and Aoi into having a fight in order to leave them separated during the trial, and she'd have an easier time getting away with things. (Hoping to make her an actually good liar this time)
Now the coolest part for me: Byakuya and Aoi as parts of Kyoko.
Have you watched Death Note? This is sort of like that. Remember how L was smarter than Near and Mello individually, but when together they were able to match him or overcome him?
This is sort of like that. Neither Aoi or Byakuya can come close to Kyoko's intelligence on their own, but they may be able to match her if they work together, complementing their flaws and increasing their strenghts.
I imagine Celestia killing Kyoko in chapter 5 and Byakuya and Aoi having to put their brains together for the hardest trial so far.
A thing that worried me a little was free time events.
Characters like Makoto are very friendly, so it's logical they'd go out of their way to spend time with people, but Byakuya is pretty by himself.
Still, I think it could work. Maybe Byakuya decides to spend time with people to learn how "Commoners" or other ultimates live, similar to how he asks about it to Makoto in his own free time events.
Anyway, that's my rambling of today. What do you think?
I doubt this would ever happen since, if we get a 1x1, I doubt both of them would >!survive, given that they are already survivors and it'd be unfair to the others.!<
Also, it'd require a big change in the story, including themes >!(Hope vs. Despair and such), but I think it could be fun.!<