RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/datingoverthirty • … • u/nowrebooting

After years of failing at OLD I feel like I never understood dating in the first place.

I sometimes figure I must be on the autism spectrum or something because I don’t really get what women expect from me on online dating. I’m not even at a loss for matches, but conversations never really get off the ground or die after the first date.

Now I’ll be the first to admit that I’m weird - I’m an extreme introvert, bad at taking initiative and terrible at small talk; after tons of dates that went nowhere I know it’s not my looks, sense of humor or even society that’s torpedo-ing my chances - it’s my personality. I’m not exciting. Still, despite the charming picture I’ve just painted of myself I also don’t think I’m so bad that nobody could ever like me. I have plenty of friends, not bad looking and can make people laugh.

One thing I’ve been wondering is the following; am I being too standoffish in my dating small talk? After growing up reading many horror stories of men making women feel uncomfortable and unsafe in general, I never really say anything that can be construed as flirty because I don’t want to come off as creepy. I don’t compliment them on their looks, don’t allude to anything remotely sexual and will take any hint towards a “no” to leave them alone. I don’t want to be an incel. It also makes me a non-confrontational robot that will ask you about your job, friends and family but won’t call you pretty unless we’re practically already married.

I don’t want to be the “nice guy” who complains about women “not giving him a chance”, but trying to avoid becoming one isn’t doing me any good. Am I crazy? Is this the result of me projecting my OLD experience on the rest of the world? Should I try being just a smidge more aggressive in saying what I feel even if it makes me feel like a creep?

EDIT: Thanks for all your replies and kind words so far! There's a whole lot of food for thought and some very valid points there.

— 0