RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/debatemeateaters • … • u/shadow_user

[Meta] Is this post a strawman?

[https://www.reddit.com/r/debatemeateaters/comments/a3p9o4/valuing\_sentience\_is\_meaningless\_when\_every/](https://www.reddit.com/r/debatemeateaters/comments/a3p9o4/valuing_sentience_is_meaningless_when_every/)

​

The post disagrees with a common vegan position, that beings should be valued based on sentience. The post does so while using a particular definition of sentience, one the OP later acknowledges that they know is not the definition that vegans commonly use. Isn't that a strawman?

​

As an honest mistake, it's not a big deal. But when I pointed out the issue to OP, they refused to acknowledge any issues in their post. All I'm asking for, is that the vegan position is conveyed accurately before being rebutted.

​

In general when having disagreements with users, I would just move on. I find this post particularly concerning because it is authored by a mod of the sub.

​

Disclaimer: [Here](https://www.reddit.com/r/debatemeateaters/comments/a3p9o4/valuing_sentience_is_meaningless_when_every/eb8cd5v/) is the discussion I had with the author of the post.

— 0