The story's relationship with suicide, intervention and autonomy
Thoughout the game we are shown or teased multiple instances of suicide in unique circumstances and unique reactions to each instance by other characters within the game. It's so fascinating to me how different each one feels and how you may catch yourself feeling differently depending on the circumstances. To keep us on the same page the instances I'm referring to are:
- Gustave's suicide attempt after losing most of Expedition 33. - Sciel's suicide attempt after losing Pierre. - Painted Alicia's Gommage in Act 3 - Painted Clea's suicide at the end of her boss fight. - Painted Verso's suicide in his ending.
In every instance, each situation is portrayed negatively, or at least one character reacts to it negatively. However in the context of each of the Painted Dessendres, there are arguments for why the suicide is justifiable, the primary arguments being: 1. It's their choice to make, and 2. Their circumstances are so much bleaker compared to others.
Gustave and Sciel are considered some of the most emotionally mature characters in the game and sometimes I see people claim that if the Dessendres handled their grief the same way these 2 did, then things would be better. However, both characters notably attempted suicide and *did* *not* stop of their own choice. Both are still alive due to the intervention of others. These interventions allowed them a moment to look outside their despair and find a reason to keep on living and become better people. This is the same line of thought used when PVerso is upset that his sister chooses to be gommaged. As well as Maelle's reasoning to keep PVerso alive in her ending. That they can and should be convinced to keep on going.
On the opposite end, peope argue that a person's autonomy matters above all else:
- PAlicia has been betrayed by her brother and had nothing left to keep her going. It's her choice.
- PVerso has lived too long and is a man born from the grief of a family's loss of their son and believes that so long as he exists the suffering will never end.
- PClea has been transformed into a living Nevron factory and their is no known way to stop this, so death is the only way out.
- Some consider Maelle's ending to be a form of suicide as well, but justify it through either the fact that she has no future or hope outside of the canvas and everything she loves is in the Canvas. (I'm choosing to not factor in the survival Lumiere as a reason to stay in the canvas because it is demonstratvely possible for her to come and go from the canvas and save it's people without actually staying in it herself. This is a discussion purely about the topic of suicide and not a debate or justification for either ending).
There's a constant tug of war between whether a person should decide for themselves and if their loved ones should be allowed to intervene. There's also a nuance as to how that intervention should look like.
- Renoir is an example of physically forceful intervention. Which he justifies through the fact that he's been in the situation himself and that the people he is trying to save refuse to see reason. That he's tried talking to them and this is the only option he is left with.
- Lune sits next to Gustave in a way where if Gustave shoots, she'll also die as the bullet will pass through his head and hit her. While it's more passive, it also forces Gustave to actually consider killing a friend to end his own suffering, from then on Lune, refuses to let Gustave dwell on those thoughts, constantly curbing them whenever they come up. Some can see it as her being argumentative and not letting him process his emotions.
- You have Esquie in the middle who didn't even know Sciel and saved her purely as a good samaritan, Sciel didn't even know how she was saved. Would she have fought against it if she was conscious at the time?
- You have PVerso who simply wanted to talk his sister out of it. Despite his own actions leading her to this decision, so it could be argued that you don't have a right to talk someone out of something when you are part of the problem.
Depending on who you are as a person, any of the above methods can be seen as the most necessary way to get through to someone, or see it as a complete violation of that person's autonomy. And it's hard, because people are also unique, some people can be talked out of a situation, but others have to be dragged kicking and screaming before they come to their senses.
PVerso's situation is also unique in that he cannot actually kill himself, and everyone with the power to do so, refuses to, so he takes matters into his own hands, at the cost of the canvas. But he also has lived an unnaturally long life and it has been one of constant battle and suffering and loss. The same type of despair Gustave goes through, he has gone through multiple times in a single lifetime with no sign of it ending and who knows if Gustave wouldn't break in a similar way if he was in that situation. It's a difficult discussion because, with the current circumstances, it is not possible for him to die without also dooming the world, the closest he comes is with Renoir at the beginning of Act 3 and Maelle prevents it immediately.
It's all fascinating, I went into this game expecting discussions of grief but I never I'd be discussing suicide as much as I have. I'm left considering that sometimes going on may not be the way, depending on the situation. And my only solace at the moment is that what the Painted Dessendre's go through is not something that can happen to someone in the real world.
However, I ultimately believe that as much as a person has a right to make their own choices, to end their own suffering, euthanasia as an example. I do also think that people have a right to at least try and talk them out of it. As long as they try, success isn't a necessity.
This next paragraph goes into personal anecdotes, you don't really have to consider or read it, but I feel like I should let it out.
I've personally lost two uncles and a close friend to suicide and my feelings on each one are very unique.
- The first uncle, I've always been angry at, and still am. He had accumulated a lot of debt and with no way to pay it back, he ended himself, abandoning his family. I've always seen it as him being a coward and haven't forgiven him for it. He never even tried reaching out to his family or friends for help and that's what hurts me the most, I feel he let his pride get in the way, and wasn't willing to accept that his despair was hurting those around him, especially over choices he made and a failure to take accountability.
- The second uncle, had a stroke and completely lost the use of his left arm and most of his speech. He had to stop working. My family tired our best to take care of him and he just couldn't go on like that. I don't know how to feel because I didn't know what he went through. I don't know how he must've felt and I don't know what I could've done to make him feel better but I'm not mad at him, just sad. I saw him cry more during that period than any other time I've known him.
- My friend had been diagnosed with depression and I had been going through my own depressive episode at the time so I didn't even really talk to her about it until it was too late, I figured she would work her way through it, alone, like I did. I always hated myself for that, I'm under no illusion that I actually could've stopped her but she died thinking I don't care about her and that's always going to be a regret I have to live with, so I always make sure my friends understand how I feel about them and how I can be there for them. Maybe it could be enough, but I'll never know, I have to try anyways.
Each of these hurt me in different ways and I can absolutely see how they affected my outlook on this game, but at the same time I very much appreciate how this game made me think back to those moments in my own life with new eyes and really think about how those people must've felt in the moment.