If the party actually becomes/is an evil party, this entire campaign will become significantly better.
I know a similarly titled post was recently made ("Better story with an evil party,") but this post is **significantly** different in content.
##Why I think the story is better served if the party is evil:
I think this campaign becomes "top" tier if they actually become evil and/or release Predathos. It makes the "should we save the Gods" debates so much better, because we (as the audience) are like "OF COURSE YOU SHOULD SAVE THE GODS." As such, we think the answer is clear and obvious, which makes these conversations frustrating af. But, if the characters are actually falling into evil alignments/aren't the heroes we expect them to be, then these conversations serve as some significant signs that this party won't make the "right" decision.
These conversations would show the audience that the party is following the wrong path, in part due to ignorance but also due to character flaws. It would paint these conversations in a new light. Currently, it has honestly come off as highly ignorant (somewhat moronic) PCs struggling to come to the obvious conclusion, but maybe this is a party of morally flawed individuals trying to rationalize a horrible choice they want to or will make. This reluctance to save the gods makes more sense if the party is or is becoming evil.
Imo, a (mostly) evil party is a cool take. Tbf, I don't think they'll ever be "mustache twirling" evil. They may even think they're doing the right thing, but don't most villains?
##How this could reasonably play out:
I know some people may point at M9 and say they were evil, but (imo) they were more morally grey rather than evil. This party actually seems like multiple members are actively falling into an evil alignment.
We have Laudna becoming more Delilah-esque and wanting to worship genocidal Titans. Ashton is basically outright saying "fuck the gods" and also wanting to worship genocidal titans. (Meanwhile both of them seemed horned up for Asmodeus). Now, we have Fearne seemingly signing up for a pact with Asmodeus, a betrayer god. Even if it was done on a whim, swearing allegiance to Asmodeus is, ultimately, undoubtedly evil.
Of course, Asmodeus is technically a prime deity. So, at face value, it would seem Asmodeus would want to stop the release of Predathos. However, he's the god of lies and deceit. I could see him wanting to prevent the full release of Predathos for his own self-preservation, but he may still be planning to allow the release of some of Predathos' power. His goal, of course, would be to use Predathos to kill some of the prime deities as revenge and then use his/the other Gods' champions to reseal Predathos. A partial release of Predathos is similar to how only a portion of Tharizdun seeped into the material plane, so it is seemingly not without precedent. I think the party will always choose to kill Ludinus, but with Asmodeus in the picture, I could see a way to still (at least partially) release Predathos. Ultimately, should the campaign go this route, I think the party would/could redeem themselves by sealing the part of Predathos they released.
##Conclusion
I digress. I think the worst parts of the campaign, should the party (or a significant portion of the party) actually become evil, would become painted in a new light. One that really makes this campaign wild. Vox Machina saved the world and became famous. M9 saved the world but no one knew. Hells Bells fucked the world. (and then maybe rectified their mistake?). Because of recent events (Asmodeus and Fearne), I'm more intrigued in this campaign and I'm withholding judgment to see how this plays out. I'm interested to see what decisions this party makes, because sometimes the worst decisions are the best decisions (at least in DnD).
But, hey, maybe I'm just being optimistic and we'll see them align themselves with Titans and Betrayer Gods and the lore will be retroactively changed to make the party come off as the good guys. (Although I doubt that, because [there's no way Matt retcons this.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BS0bH_qDIAw)) Maybe the party will all have a change of heart and become totally pro-Gods (I doubt that as well).
^^edited ^^for ^^formatting ^^purposes.