RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/fansofcriticalrole • … • u/kwade_charlotte

S3 E77 math

Edit: went back and watched through the last part of the episode.

4:28:44 Matt (paraphrased):*The DC part way through was 11 or higher... as it progresses it steps up until it gets to 15.*

The second roll was an 11, so I'm going to revise the math below as it wasn't a linear increase as I'd assumed.

​

Right, so I've seen a couple folks posting things like "Matt gave Tal a softball", or "there's no consequences to their actions". I wanted to run the numbers to show just how unlikely Ash surviving that ordeal really was, and how dangerous that entire sequence was.

Let's just ignore the fire damage that drained a level 11 and level 9 healer (because of Fearne's Rogue levels). 5e is pretty notorious for being soft on character death and everything being a meatsack of HP. Needless to say, without healing that's over 200 points of fire damage, with it (as long as your HP max is enough to not insta-kill you) it's nothing.

The real trick here was 10 consecutive Con saves, with one failure being insta-death. That's pretty rare to begin with in the game, there are very few instances of things that just outright kill you if you fail a die roll. To have to pass 10 rolls in a row is pretty insane.

Here's the math, ~~based on my understanding of the mechanic Matt used. I believe he stated that the DC began at 11, and increased to 15 staying there for the remainder of the rolls. If I missed something there feel free to let me know and I can easily re-run the numbers.~~

See edit at top, I'm going to assume the actual mechanics were:

DC11, DC11, DC12, DC12, DC13, DC13, DC14, DC14, DC15, DC15

Ash has a VERY impressive +8 Con save (already putting him well above your average person), but still passing that many rolls is absolutely crazy.

If the above is correct, then we have the following odds at success for each individual roll:

~~90% \* 85% \* 80% \* 75% \* 70% (plus 5 more at 70% after this one)~~

90% \* 90% \* 85% \* 85% \* 80% \* 80% \* 75% \* 75% \* 70% \* 70%

The odds of making THAT MANY rolls in a row is **~~5.4%~~**~~.~~ **10.3%**

Slightly better odds than rolling a ~~nat 20.~~ 19-20 on a single die roll.

Even with the ring (which saved his ass), the odds of what Tal pulled off was **~~7.7%~~**~~.~~ **12.9%**

(edit2: within a couple %, because doing this the "right" way makes the math INSANELY difficult).

Addendum to edit2: since we don't know the exact mechanics used and can only guess, here's the result if the actual mechanic were DC11, DC11, DC11, DC11, DC11, DC12, DC13, DC14, DC15, DC15: **16.4% to 21%** (plus or minus a couple % due to the ability to ignore one save)

So the tree was correct - it was *exceptionally* dangerous and *almost certain* death. Ash should have died, but the dice told the story. There's a reason Matt looked so sick throughout the sequence - he knew this was practically a death sentence (and it really should have been).

— 0