FFXIV UI Design Insanity
I love FFXIV. The story is good, the art is fantastic, job designs hit the mark for the most part, the set pieces are best in the business and it touches my nostalgia bone well as someone who grew up with the series.
However, I am more or less continuously in awe of how utterly incompetent, if not outright hostile, the UI design can be.
For the most part, I'm not going to reference plogons here (except for one screenshot where I just could not be bothered to disable SimpleTweaks to detail just how utterly absurd crafting can be). Additionally, all but the crafting example is something that has been changed/added since Shadowbringers' release (so this isn't just me picking on outdated UI elements Square hasn't adjusted)
||
First, there's whatever the fuck these tabs are.
https://imgur.com/U8yGsXK
The problem with these is that they're genuinely a good idea, AND ALMOST NEVER FUCKING USED.
Instead, we get menus like these:
https://i.imgur.com/UIeCC2I.png
Now, this is the worst example, but good fucking lord what an example it is. Four completely non descript buttons, multiple of which could be covered using the (informative and controller friendly) UI tabs linked above. "Prize Exchange I" is nothing but weapons, "Prize Exchange II" is nothing but armor. This is a menu that was actually changed at some point during Endwalker, though I don't recall which patch. It wasn't improved.
||
Next, Island Sanctuary.
Credit where credit is due. The switching of automation was a hilarious joke of a UI that was.. mostly fixed. However.. https://imgur.com/nZkvQNs
Why isn't there a search bar? Why isn't there a basic "sort alphabetically"? What are you doing?
https://i.imgur.com/nvuteHd.png
Why do I have to delete these, *individually*, every couple weeks? Better yet, why isn't there a "Apply to all Workshops" button?
Didn't take a picture of another complaint, but why do you kill all the UI windows:
a) when I'm in a gathering animation
b) when I open the granary window
Weirdly, I actually want to see my stocks when I'm doing those two things.
There's quite a bit of other UI weirdness with Island Sanctuary, but I don't want to make this an IS post.
||
https://imgur.com/p99qvEW
I'm too lazy to make pictures of the all problems here, but in text form: None of the main categories default to a subcategory when clicked, which means you *always* have to click several times to open any given list. The bottom four main categories literally only have one subcategory. Most of the main categories that *do* have subcategories have *very* obvious primary subcategories (ie the Ironworks gear in the case of DoW/DoM)
Crafter and Gatherer Materia menus start with the Cluster trades at the top, despite literally the only source of them being incredibly bad Khloe trades.
||
https://i.imgur.com/ctscVvz.png
What deranged person made this both demount and require a confirmation to use? It only moves you 500 yalms to begin with! There are *lots* of absolutely *miserable, pointless* confirmation dialogue boxes everywhere. If it's something I can reverse, at zero cost, within 10 seconds, ***you do not need to check if it's okay*.**
||
https://i.imgur.com/CWSjasj.png
So this is my image that features SimpleTweaks, and also is an old problem. Plogon enjoyers will probably think nothing of that Switch Job button in the corner, but people who get to suffer from the nightmare that is multiclass crafting without plogons.
For those who don't know, crafting an item places you into a crafting stance of sorts that sticks until you close the crafting log. While in this stance, you cannot make any non crafting action (including movement, or changing jobs..) until the crafting log is closed. So of course, you have to close the crafting log, wait for the "putting your tools away" animation, change jobs, open the crafting log again, scroll back to the recipe you want (because the crafting log helpfully forgets what you were doing when you change jobs). Most high end items take items from at least three different crafting jobs, so you can imagine why this might be frustrating.
Or you install SimpleTweaks, it adds a "Switch Job" button in the obvious place, prevents the Crafting Log from being closed and makes the UI feel reasonable.
||
Grab bag of random shit that came up as I was writing this absurd ranty post:
Item search doesn't know about certain inventories unless you've accessed them *this* session -- nobody can me can modify my Glamour Dresser, Saddlebag or Retainers, the state of these should never be a mystery.
Related to the previous point about Yes/No dialogues but at no point will extracting Materia have any downside whatsoever, stop confirming it.
Literally everything about crafted combat gear upgrades.
Not being able to upgrade relics without equipping a dummy weapon.
Materia removal not having a "remove all from item" button. (good work on the "attach materia until it works" functionality tho)
Making macros barely functional for combat (the lack of fractional waits makes automation a non starter)
||
None of these are huge issues in a vacuum, it's only when they stack up and up and up is when I really start to question what Square's UI design team is thinking.
Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.