RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/fragrance • … • u/poop_dawg

Why do I like the smell of candles but not most perfumes/colognes?

I feel like I must be doing something wrong. I'm a big candle girl and there aren't many candle scents I don't like. I'd say that's generally true of scents everywhere; I am not easily disturbed by smells. However, I am SO picky with perfume and cologne (at least when I test them; when I notice fragrances on people, they're usually pleasant to me). I've learned this because I've recently become obsessed with learning about perfume, so I've gotten some samples and have tested fragrances at stores. I'd say 90+% of wearable fragrances are a 3/5 or below for me, even ones that seem to be universally adored! Some fragrances I've tested that I have been shocked to not enjoy (I'd rate all 0-2/5):

\- YSL Libre (EDP) & Libre Intense (EDP & parfum)

\- YSL Black Opium (parfum) - this one smelled like cigarettes to me

\- Burberry Goddess (EDP, EDP intense & parfum)

\- Kilian Love, Don't Be Shy

\- Versace Crystal Noir (EDT)

\- Carolina Herrera Good Girl (all strengths and most of the flankers)

\- Tom Ford Black Orchid

\- Guerlain Shalimar

\- Ariana Grande Cloud

...and many more. Again, most, for some reason.

I can't imagine there's much room for a mistake to be made when I test. I spray on a tester strip, then I let it air out for several seconds, then sniff. I don't do a ton of fragrances back to back to back. I try to give my nose time to readjust and smell my own skin before going back in (Emma from Perfumerism recommends this over smelling coffee beans šŸ¤·ā€ā™€ļø).

Another strange factor is that all my favorite scents have been blind buys - Lost Cherry, Missing Person, and Amor Amor are what I keep in rotation. I LOVE those scents, and I bought them all before I knew anything about perfume. I purchased based on vibes alone - which is dumb, but somehow I've never blind bought a fragrance I didn't end up loving.

Can anyone help me figure out what's going on? I want to like more perfumes. :(

Edit: I should add that I have tested perfumes in person the same way and have loved them - Armani SWY Intense (bought), all of Billie Eilish's perfumes, and Mont Blanc Explorer all come to mind.

— 0