In light of recent posts, here's an open-ended discussion topic: Is is possible to make a compelling open-world space game?
Figured I start us off with a gamedev/design topic since everyone seems to be talking about this sort of thing.
Starfield sparked a pretty deep discussion between my brother and I about its shortcomings, which led to a more general debate about the design elements of open-world games and space open-world games in particular.
Our conclusion is that it is likely not possible to create an open-world game in the style of Bethesda games in space, for a couple of primary reasons:
* space is mostly empty * space is very large
The soul of an open-world adventure game in any genre or setting is serendipitous discovery, from random dungeons and lore in the Elder Scrolls series, to player notes, side bosses, and hidden items in Souls-like games, and so on.
However, space is large and empty. If a game is set on spaceships in space, how can there be serendipitous discovery? We assert that the only way to make a compelling open-world space game is to limited the physical area the game takes place in to something that makes logical sense to have a lot of "stuff" scattered around, like a Star Wars-style asteroid field, a single planet with a bunch of moons and space stations, or something like that.
Thoughts?