RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/gamedev • … • u/OhUmHmm

Case Study: 325k youtube views, impact on sales is 0

I want to clarify this is not my game, but I was recently browsing the situation about the game CuffBust by Two Star Games.

When searching on youtube, I was surprised to see this video by a youtube channel with 2M views posted yesterday:

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMgtHca2VCo](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMgtHca2VCo)

The video gathered 325k views in about 1 day. This makes it the 8th most viewed youtube video about CuffBust, and if you exclude the release trailer and a short that was posted as a video, it's actually #6.

But when you look at the concurrent players:

[https://steamcharts.com/app/2592220](https://steamcharts.com/app/2592220)

There's no bump at all, at least nothing I can see. Some mitigating circumstances:

1. Mixed reviews on Steam as a hard gate for consumers to purchase 2. Based on youtube comments, some people don't know what game it is. (The youtubers mention it but quickly) 3. I don't know this youtuber, but it seems they specialize in minecraft and roblox and skew heavily toward a younger crowd that might not buy games.

I have no desire to beat a dead horse or bag on Two Star Games, but I think this makes an amazing case study that streamers and content creators, even with hundreds of thousands of views, do not always convert to sales. At least in this case, not even a little.

Regarding the mitigating factors:

For #1 -- the mixed reviews, I think the recent Battlefield 6 and a bunch of other FPS games have middling reviews

[https://store.steampowered.com/app/2807960/Battlefield\_6/](https://store.steampowered.com/app/2807960/Battlefield_6/)

City Skylines 2 as well: [https://store.steampowered.com/app/949230/Cities\_Skylines\_II/](https://store.steampowered.com/app/949230/Cities_Skylines_II/)

and the Persona 5 spinoff, Monster Hunter, etc.

Yet these titles all do quite well. So I don't think it's only about the actual positive review %. A sizeable number of people will purchase a game despite this. Though the lack of content in the game (at release) may be particularly damning for consumers.

For #2, I do think this might have been a small issue for some, though youtube does list the game above the comments automatically.

Personally I think #3 is one likely culprit, and what inspired me to write the post. Ages ago, I heard that classical music radio stations didn't attract the biggest audiences, but it was a very select audience, and so they could charge more for ads, per listener. Perhaps this is something similar.

When selecting a game idea, I think it's good to consider the disconnect between streamable content and playable content. I'm now of the opinion that streams might inform a viewer about the game's existence, and may explain the gameplay. But that by itself is not enough to convince people to purchase a game. Even if the streamer/youtuber honestly seems to be having a fun time with memorable moments.

I think there's a lot more to unpack about CuffBust, but I just wanted to highlight this case study. Especially for those considering buying streams, or even sending free keys to streamers.

— 0