RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/harrypotter • … • u/No_Cartographer7815

Dumbledore was right to try to keep Sirius in Grimmauld Place

Dumbledore gets a lot of flak for keeping Sirius "locked up", both from fans and from Harry, but looking back on Sirius' history, I'd have to say that Dumbledore was right to do so. Let's have a look at Sirius' track record.

* In the beginning of Prisoner of Azkaban, Sirius goes to Little Whinging to see Harry after his escape. He sneaks up on Harry at Magnolia Crescent, and almost immediately Harry senses him and draws his wand.

* Sirius then tries to break into Gryffindor Tower, and almost immediately alerts the whole school to his presence by attacking a painting.

* During Gryffindor's quidditch game against Hufflepuff, Sirius goes to watch Harry. He goes right into the stands, and Harry sees him yet again.

* After stealing the passwords to Gryffindor tower, he goes straight into the third year boys' dorm and wakes them all up by standing over Ron with a knife in his hand.

* Later on in PoA, Harry sees with Crookshanks him by just looking out of the Hogwarts window.

* Towards the end of the book he goes to get Wormtail off Ron, and ends up dragging Ron with him and being chased by Harry and Hermione. Then Lupin and Snape both get dragged into it.

* During Goblet of Fire he goes to talk to Harry through the fireplace and yet again they are seconds away from being caught. To be fair it was Ron who wouldn't have turned him in, but it could have been anyone.

* In the beginning of Order of the Phoenix, he accompanies Harry and the others to King's Cross, and is seen by one of the main Death Eaters (Lucius).

* Then he is again seconds away from being caught in the Gryffindor fireplace, by Umbridge this time.

Hardly a master of stealth. Almost every time he goes to do something he ends up making a mess of it. One could definitely argue that Dumbledore could have been more tactful (although we don't know what conversations happened between them), but it's hard to argue against him wanting to keep Sirius hidden.

— 0