Unpopular Opinion: Neville killing Nagini is kind of a cop-out
EDIT: SHEESSH i knew it would be unpopular but damn
unpopular opinion but the "Neville kills nagini" moment is kind of a cop-out, and I don't think enough people talk about it.
the actual fight the series (since GoF) was building toward was Neville vs Bellatrix. she's the one who tortured his parents into insanity. that's four books of setup. instead we get Neville killing Nagini, which is a nice "quiet hero steps up" beat, sure, but it's not the personal reckoning his arc had been promising this whole time.
Molly gets the Bellatrix kill instead. great moment for Molly. but it completely sidesteps the harder story, which is: what happens when the one person in the entire series with the most reason to want revenge actually has to decide who he becomes, instead of just being handed the catharsis.
and this isn't a random gripe, the whole series is obsessed with revenge as a corrupting force. it's Voldemort's entire origin. it's half of Snape's arc. it's the thing Harry keeps getting tempted by. Neville was set up to be the answer to that theme, the guy with every reason to turn vengeful who chooses Herbology and defending his friends instead.
except the books never actually make him choose that. they never put Bellatrix in front of him. so his growth ends up reading as circumstantial, not an actual moral choice.
basically his arc is "brave boy finds courage" when it could've been "boy with every justification for hatred chooses mercy anyway." harry gets to choose - after all that voldemort did, he still casts expelliarmus. Neville deserved the same. I could have done without Molly killing bellatrix, it was cool but honestly not as "epic" as it could have been.