I hate myself
Hate myself for not elaborating and explaining myself further on my previous post on Arlecchino from Genshin Impact. I want to apologize (not to her though), as I'm now realizing that this may have left some of you who saw that post confused, and therefore I believe I deserve a post about me and how I acted that day (even if it breaks the rules of no real people)
Aside from that, since the thought of being in the same subreddit as her makes my skin crawl greatly (even more the thought of it being for a greater reason than hers), I have taken the opportunity to use this post to do a way more detailed explanation on why I really, REALLY don't enjoy this character and I believe she's little more than one of the biggest examples on how the devs fail to write morally complex characters (or at the very least, are extremely lazy when doing so)
Being completely honest, ALMOST every aspect of her character is so lame to me that I don't even know where to start, so I'll just throw different important pieces of her writing while expressing my disdain and disappointed on them
First is her backstory, which is arguably the worst part, like this is the textbook definition of a 2014 OC: "Hey guys this is my oc Arlecchino I hope you like her she's very complex and not a good person she's also part of a criminal organization but don't worry she doesn't actually like them and was forced to join them at a very young age she also had her friend Clervie who was the only one who understood her but died because of the previous and cruel caretaker Crucabena who is very evil and cruel and also evil and made the children kill each other despite making no logical sense but don't worry guys Arlecchino has a curse that allows her to have cool powers and she killed Crucabena with them also did I mention that Crucabena was evil guys? I hope I did also did ya know that Arlecchino also kills predators, and did ya know she actually cares a lot about the kids and has tea parties with her friends anyways I hope you like her guys bye" like I'm sorry... is this considered good writing in Genshin??
Yeah, apparently a high-ranking Harbinger wants the children to kill each other for whatever reason just to make Arlecchino look better, I swear Crucabena is possibly the worst and most bland character in the entire game, I genuinely struggle to understand how someone could've approved this, this is the example of how you do a morally gray character the easy way: you make a character, and then you make a monster with no heart, you copypaste one of the monster's traits but to a lesser scale into the character, then scream from across the room "MOOOM! I'm a writer now!" even I've seen some Arle fans agreeing that this was some bs
And on the "she kills predators and creeps" bit, yeah, this is another issue, the devs want to claim she's "morally grey" or whatever but were too scared of people hating her- no... even the THOUGHT of people hating her so they had to avoid giving her any genuinely unsavory traits or conflicting moments for the player, like of you name all of this you can already see all the stuff you need to be a garantized fan favorite:
Kills pedophiles and wealthy assholes, is cold and stern on the outside, cares about kids, looks like a "butch lesbian" (whatever that is), is the main contestant for yuri ships, extremely reasonable at all times, like... is this supposed to be morally thought provoking or something? This feels like an obvious cheap way to avoid any real naunced discussion about her character or her actions - because, let me break it down for you: she's an ABUSER, yes, not just a GROOMER, but an ABUSER, she runs an orphanage that turns children into soldiers, and I don't think this needs to be clarified, but unfortunately some people still seem to don't get it, and listen, I don't care, I don't care if she's a bad person, a story needs characters that fulfill a role, but in the end this doesn't work if the story is not even gonna adress her issues properly
And of course, before you call me a filthy lore skipper, I am aware "But her issues are addressed seriously, just read Lyney and Freminet's voicelines about her" and that's nice and all, but honestly? none of that seems to really matter when it's simply an 1% of her entire arc, like okay, it is addressed that the children actually die in one of her trailers, but with a little bit of thought process you can already see that this tragedy can be reduced to "Look how cool and badass I look while I kill the murderer of my child! Pull for me!" It's so obvious and over the top I feel like I was the one being played with and not the other way around, the worst part is that this entire conflict with the children and the orphanage are practically resolved by the end of her SQ, where Lyney and Lynette decide to stay even after Arlecchino was willing to let them go (because she's so likeable and children need to grow am I right guys), which gives no room for any development or grow within her character or other's opinions on her
And this is another issue, by having her actual harmful traits be pushed aside in voicelines or her own sq, the devs got a lot of time to make her noble aspects be shown explicitedly on your face on the main quest to make you desperately like her, it's like her entire moral conflict is simply a "description" of her or something, like they designed a perfectly naunced character and then they give her the role and personality of a sweetheart hero that is good and rarely does anything off the rails, and don't start with the bs of "she has to put up a nice facade" because we both know that during Nod-Krai this wasn't the case
Now, I normally don't like attacking fanbases so I'll try to keep it brief, but I feel like this needs to be said, some of her fans can be very selective on what aspects of her they want you to notice, because most of the times you may see them praising how complex her morality is and how neutral of a person she is with both a good side and a bad side, but when you actually dare to point out how unlikeable she or her actions can be, they jump you with the "you don't understand her character" or "she did it for a neccessary reason" like okay guys but that doesn't make me like her more, if she's a bad person and basically gets no consequences from it, It's going to feel unfair and mean-spirited
Honestly, this post doesn't even cover half of the issues I have with her and it's already very long, so I'll just end with this, and this may be a hot take but: she's a bigger Mary Sue than Mavuika, yep, and you try to argue against that, at least Mavuika had an actual decision to make before the clock stopped, Arlecchino is never outsmarted, never truly challengued, is part of a cursed bloodline that grants her powers, with Mavuika it kind of made sense because she was the hero of the plot, the narrative literally bends over backwards to make Arlecchino always look composed, always win, and is always "right", and that's why I say and I repeat - she's simply a hero with a "morally grey" character description that you can read in about 2 or 3 minutes and nothing would change or affect the plot in any significant way, her conflict is swallow
I'm done, there's a lot of things I still want to say but the point is, Arlecchino is not well written, at least in my opinion, and I hope this point made it clear what she's nothing more than a boring, pathetic excuse of a complex character but without actually having the writing to earn that title, she's not completely bad though, I admit, her design and lore is cool, and who knows, maybe the devs will surprise us someday, but as for right now, she just remains as another woman character in Genshin whose "bad traits" are either pushed away, or a marketing plan to make her look "badass and cool" while they make her the hero and fan favorite of the overarching plot once they are done describing how "morally grey" she is without actually showing it