I really don't like the discourse around early 3D games/movies/media and liminal spaces and how it mocks modern audiences for seeing things as "weird."
I'm not sure if I should call this a rant, a perspective, or what... But I really kind of dislike how people get themselves in knots over how a lot of the youngsters see older media that first utilized 3D animation/graphics as evoking liminal vibes.
Take note that I'm someone who was born in 1989 and thus was a kid who saw a lot of the early 3D games, cartoons, and graphics that were being produced throughout the 90s, and I can remember the absolute hype and discussion about how it was all "cutting edge" at the time. I still consider the original *Toy Story* to be *the best damn animated movie* of my childhood (what's a Lion King, again?). And don't get me started how I would have absolutely loved to explore some of those early 3D landscapes made in the day.
But also, it's been 30 years since *Super Mario 64* released (and 1 year more from that since the first *Toy Story* came out), and frankly, even if those pieces of media were pushing the envelope back in the mid 90s, to a modern audience, they're going to look incredibly dated and lacking in some form or another.
*Super Mario 64*, for as great as game it is to play, feels absolutely minimal and hostile with how there's so little friendly NPCs in the game, as well as the fact that even for a Mario game, it's pretty weird with all the blocky geometries and lack of the fun, vivid colors that were typical of previous Mario games before hand and the games that would come out on the Gamecube later on. *Toy Story* generally has a sense of "airlessness" and as in the Pizza Planet scene above, just looks like a half-baked attempt at making a city area with a *handful* of plastic buildings and cars.
So of course, to someone who mostly grew up with games that had more vibrant set pieces filled with all sorts of characters or watched CGI movies that could include more details and objects, going back to these is going to seem weird and very uncanny. And frankly I personally don't have a problem with that because despite what little nostalgia I have, I know how tech moves on and how art evolves over the years. What's groundbreaking and cool in 1996 is not going to be the same in 2026.
Of course, seeing the way people get all defensive about kids saying that these old pieces of media have a weird vibe to them is what annoys me. Video games and animation are two very tech-heavy mediums where a lot could happen because of a single innovation (just look at some animation that was made before Steamboat Willie of the early 20th century and compare it to animation just right after that). Getting mad because a kid doesn't find your childhood game where the textures weren't even able to go up to 512x512 pixels or the character doesn't even have a mouth "charming" is really kind of misunderstanding how media ages and can change over time.
I guess between being someone who plays with a lot of "art tech" and has actually had discourse around the liminal spaces thing, I feel like the people who get mad about people calling something like *Super Mario 64* a liminal game are just unaware of how things have changed and evolved.