RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/hisdarkmaterials • … • u/Lady_Beatnik

I love how the I Ching is apparently legit but the tarot is not lol

(Mostly nonserious post) That was something I always wondered when reading "The Amber Spyglass" and seeing Dr. Malone use the I Ching to speak to Dust, and the angels confirm it works, saying there are "many methods" of doing so. Naturally, my first thought was tarot decks?

But then comes this guy like, "Oh no, that's bullshit, only MY special specific oracle deck works," says an actual alchemist.

Bro what lol??? I know he's an antagonistic character whose words can't necessarily be trusted and doesn't necessarily reflect how Pullman himself thinks this universe operates, but I just find the implication of this arbitrary distinction so hilarious. Like *that's* where he draws the line?

"Computers that talk to angels?"

Pullman: Yes.

"Compass that points to random symbols you need to intuit?"

Pullman: Hell yes.

"The I Ching?"

Pullman: All cultures are valid.

"Invisible shapeshifting animal familiars that people can see if they learn to look through the air in a state of meditative calm?"

Pullman: Truest shit ever written.

"But not tarot decks?"

Pullman: Don't be ridiculous, how could a pack of flimsy paper slips tell anyone anything?

OKAY

— 0