A DEEPER DIVE: Did John Tortorella actually make a career "out of playing for overtime and stacking up enough loser points to squeak into the playoffs", as one Mark Lazerus said that he did?
In an article on *The Athletic* titled "Welcome to the NHL, where dinosaurs still roam the Earth", dated December 11, 2021, Mark Lazerus made the following statement in reference to coach-turned-analyst John Tortorella.
>Why anyone would care what Tortorella, a man who’s built a career out of playing for overtime and stacking up enough loser points to squeak into the playoffs as the world’s most boring seventh or eighth seed, has to say is beyond me.
Far be it from me to just let something like this slide without actually analyzing it further. So analyze is exactly what I did.
First things first, is Lazerus' statement true? Did Tortorella's teams regularly "play for overtime" and "stack up enough loser points to squeak into the playoffs"?
Let's take a closer look.
Tortorella took over the Tampa Bay Lightning partway through the 2000-01 season. The team itself, while markedly improved over recent years, still found a way to finish behind the second-year Atlanta Thrashers. Since Tortorella coached 43 games after succeeding Steve Ludzik as coach, there's nothing to draw from here. So we'll start with the 2001-02 season.
Now, for those who don't remember the NHL in this time period, it's referred to as "The Dead Puck Era" for a reason. Games averaged a total of around five goals per game, ties were frequent, power plays were both way down and awful when they were actually on the ice. My mind's eye of the NHL in this period of time always comes back to the same thing: a skilled winger trying to carry the puck toward the net from the boards, but instead getting (literally) wrapped up by a defenseman the size of a small battleship, who then dragged him to the corner and ragdolled him as the winger tried to fling the puck toward the slot, where his center (who had no skill but was drafted 7th overall because "you can't teach size!") was engaged in a street fight with the other (planet-sized) defenseman. The puck cleared the zone, where the same thing happened on the other side. The game ended 2-0, with shots on goal being 19-15. Yawn.
**In 2001-02**, Tortorella became embroiled in a very public feud with Vincent Lecavalier, in which trade demands were made, trades were agreed to, and GMs were fired for even thinking of doing it. Yet the Lightning posted a 10-point improvement over the previous season, surging to 69 points. They finished 18 points out of the playoffs, so Lazerus' statement about trying to squeak in as a 7th or 8th seed doesn't carry any weight here.
But the Lightning played in 19 overtime games during the 82-game season, which looks like a large number. But is it? In their own division, Atlanta also played 19, Florida played 16, Washington played 19, and Carolina played *27*. Around the NHL, Detroit had 116 points...and played in 24 overtime games. Boston had 101 points, and played in 24 overtime games. There were 270 overtime games, meaning that each team played in an average of 18. Tampa Bay's 19 overtime games is hardly an outlier.
**In 2002-03**, Tortorella's Lightning team shot up to 93 points and the Southeast Division title. This earned them the #3 seed (not a 7th or 8th). Far from "squeaking in", the Lightning were 15 points ahead of the 9th-place team (the Rangers). They played in 23 overtime games, less than the 111-point Stars (24), the 105-point Avalanche (28), the 108-point Devils (24), tied with the 99-point Blues. The NHL saw 313 overtime games, so each team played a shade under 21 OT games...and the Lightning are again nowhere close to an outlier here.
Let's go forward a year, to **2003-04**. The 106-point Lightning were the top seed in the East and 2nd overall in the NHL, so they sure as hell didn't back into the playoffs. They played in 18 OT games, with a league average of 21 games per team...last I checked, that's *less* than the league average. And look, there's Colorado playing in 28 OT games. Between 2002-03 and 2003-04, the league average was 42 OT games per team. Tampa Bay played 41, Colorado played in 56. But hey, I guess Tampa Bay was obsessed with "playing for overtime".
**In 2005-06**, Tampa Bay fought tooth and nail to get into the playoffs, and did in fact squeak in as the 8th seed. They were just two points clear of Atlanta and Toronto, who finished with identical 41-33-9 record. But there's a problem....Tampa only had 6 points from OT and shootout losses, while Atlanta and Toronto had 8. And all three teams played in 18 OT games. The league total was 281 OT games, meaning each team played 18.733 OT games...and last I checked, 18.000 is below that number.
**In 2006-07**, the Lightning again barely made it into the playoffs as a 7th seed, just two points clear of 8th-seeded Toronto, three points clear of Montreal, and five points clear of Carolina. The Lightning picked up 5 points from OT/SO losses....Montreal 6, Carolina 8, and Toronto 11. The NHL had 281 OT games, so each team played in 18.733 (again). Tampa Bay's 20 is roughly one game higher than the league average.
In Tortorella's last season in Tampa **(2007-08)**, the Lightning missed the playoffs by 23 points. They also played in just 13 OT games, compared to an NHL average of 18.133.
All told, from 2001-02 through 2007-08, the Lightning under John Tortorella played in 111 games which went into overtime. The league average during this time was around 117 games, meaning that the Lightning played *fewer* overtime games than the league average. And of the two times that they squeaked into the playoffs as a 7th or 8th seed, it was with *fewer* "loser points" than the teams that they finished ahead of.
But wait! Tortorella's career didn't end in Tampa Bay. He went from there to the Rangers. Going by full seasons only...
**In 2009-10**, the Rangers missed the playoffs by a point. The league had 302 OT games in the regular season, giving each team an average of 20.133 OT games out of 82. The Rangers played in...15. And they missed the playoffs. (Montreal, who finished one point ahead of the Rangers, played in **25** OT games. Pop quiz: is 15 more or less than 25?)
**In 2010-11**, the Rangers made the playoffs as the 8th seed, just two points ahead of 9th-place Carolina. The Rangers had 5 points from OT/SO losses (tied for the fewest in the NHL)...Carolina had 11. The NHL had 297 OT games, giving each team an average of 19.8 such games. The Rangers played in...17. Carolina, who they beat into the playoffs by two points, played in 22.
**In 2011-12**, the Rangers won the East's top seed with 109 points, and were just two shy of Vancouver's league-leading 111. Since they were 20 points clear of 9th-place Buffalo, I don't think this counts as "squeaking in". Anyway, the Rangers played in 19 OT games, compared to a league average of 20 (300 OT/SO games).
**In the shortened 2012-13 season**, the Rangers were among five teams to finish with between 55-57 points in the East - all made it in. The Rangers had 56 points (with 4 OT/SO points), Ottawa had 56 points (with 6 OT/SO), the Islanders had 55 points (with 7 OT/SO). Since there was no interconference play, the Eastern average team was 9.6 OT games...the Rangers were in 12. Of course, Ottawa played in 12 as well, and the Islanders 13, so this is hardly an outlier.
With the Rangers, Tortorella's teams played in roughly seven *fewer* OT/SO games than the league average.
On to Vancouver! In **2013-14**, the Canucks played in 22 OT games and missed the playoffs. In any case, the NHL had 307 OT games, for a per-team average of 20.467. Phoenix finished one spot ahead of Vancouver in the division, and they played in 24 OT games. Winnipeg finished a point ahead of Vancouver and played in 23 OT games.
**In 2015-16**, Tortorella took over Columbus just seven games into the season. While it's not a full season, it's close enough for government work, so we'll go into that one.
Anyway, the Jackets finished second from the bottom in the East, and dead last in the division. Obviously, this is a non-playoff team, so no squeaking in there. They also played in 16 OT/SO games...the NHL had 275 such games, for a per-team average of 18.333. Even pro-rated to 82 games, Columbus still came in below the league average.
**In 2016-17**, the CBJ had 108 points (4th in the NHL), 14 points ahead of the East's 9th-place team, and not exactly squeaking into the playoffs. The team played in 19 OT games, the NHL had 289 games, so the league average was 19.267.
**In 2017-18**, it went right down to the wire...Philadelphia had 98 points, Columbus 97, New Jersey 97, and non-playoff Florida had 96. Columbus had 7 OT/SO "loser points", New Jersey 9, Florida 8...and Philadelphia **14**. (Who squeaked in here?)
Columbus played in 22 OT games, against a league average of 19.161 per team (on 297 OT/SO games). Philadelphia played in 25 such games, picking up 14 loser points, but *Columbus* is the one who squeaked in?!?!?!
**In 2018-19**, Columbus got into the playoffs with 98 points, just two ahead of non-playoff Montreal. Columbus had 4 OT/SO points, Montreal 8, but hey, what's that *really* mean?
In the regular season, the CBJ played in 14 OT/SO games. The regular season average, per team, was 17.484 (271 leaguewide games). Montreal, by the way, played in 15, which last I checked is more than Columbus' 14.
Then in **2019-20**, Columbus made the playoff cut by 13 points, so that's not really squeaking in. There were 250 leaguewide OT/SO games, which would give us an average of 16.129 per team, but teams played varying numbers of games what with the pandemic and all. There were 1,087 games played, of which 250 went to OT...that's 23%. Well, 22.999%, but either way. Since everyone played roughly the same number of games
In any case, the Jackets played in 23 OT games, which actually was the most in the NHL.
And then last year, **2020-21**, the CBJ finished 11 points out of the playoff race. Along the way, the team played in 18 OT/SO games, where the league average was 13 (195 games leaguewide).
So there you have it.
Did a John Tortorella-coached team squeak into the playoffs a single time, just even *one time*, on the basis of overtime points? In seventeen seasons, did it *ever* happen?
No.
Not one single time did it *ever* happen. The handful of times that his teams squeaked in, it was despite playing *fewer* OT games than their competitors and garnering *fewer* OT points. And the handful of times that they played a higher-than-normal number of OT games, the team either made the playoffs by a mile or missed by a mile. Not one time in seventeen full seasons did a Tortorella team do what Mr. Lazerus said that he "built a career" out of.
Not once.
It turns out that there *are* dinosaurs roaming the Earth: reporters who don't bother doing their research, and just expect the rest of us to nod along like brainless bobbleheads when they spout nonsense.