RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/horror • … • u/Pessimistic_Gemini

So I just finished Return to Silent Hill

I've seen this movie for a while now on Hulu these last few months and with Halloween fast approaching, I thought this was as good a time as any to finally give this a watch. And honestly... I'm pleasantly surprised with it.

Now I've not seen reviews of this at all over the months since its initial release in theaters, and I've not played much of the original Silent Hill 2 game yet myself. Heck I got a copy of the remake in my library for the last couple years now and just haven't gotten around to booting it up on my PS5. But from all that I've gotten the grasp of over the years of knowing about it, I ended up finding this to be a lot more faithful than I expected it to be.

Now the casting of James may not be exactly like what would be expected with the game, but for what its worth the casting overall made this even more engaging than it would've ever been. The parts where he was going through Silent Hill in its more corrupted state was some of the best stuff in the film in itself with how trippy and adrenaline pumping they ended up being, and all without having to rely on some cheap jumpscares to make them look like such.

Pair all that with how much it retains the game's themes of grief, loss, regret amongst others, and the fact that they utilized some of the more memorable songs from the games themselves, and you have yourself quite an overlooked and potentially underrated video game movie adaptation in recent memory.

As it is here, I'd gladly watch this again over having to watch that over ANY of those live action Resident Evil films, and that includes the more recent one from a month ago.

— 0