Haunting of Hill House was just weird
(Minimal spoilers, nothing too crazy)
I've finished reading Haunting of Hill House. Here is my summary of the problems I felt.
To be perfectly honest it became a struggle for me to continue reading it after a point. My favorite series ever is the series (loosely) based on this book and also Bly Manor. Now I have to add some clarification before I get too many comments on ~comparing the book with the series; I am completely aware that these are different media and should be treated as such. I really love the "frozen fear" vibe of haunting stories. The series did an exceptionally good job at that department and I got carried away with expectations, although I could understand that not just the media but the times they were created are also profoundly different; the book is a classic and the series is a modern piece.
While I did like many parts of the book and its story, I also cannot say that I enjoyed it as a whole.
I had several problems with it and I am very much looking forward on your comments about these:
The two assistants I think that the characters are very weird in a bad way, especially Theodora and Eleanor. Throughout the whole book they are treated as and acting as literal children, to the point that it became very annoying and uncalled for. There are many parts of the story where they just run off doing "silly" things that are irrelevant to the story and the atmosphere, like playing around in nature, and what makes these stand out is that they are like this from the very beginning. I would say that if you go to a notoriously haunted house with just a few strangers and a VERY SPECIFIC task/mission, you wouldn't start acting as if it was a vacation. They are told to observe, take notes, they never do that. Luke is more invested in the discoveries even though he is only there because of the contract. It is stated in the story that only the two girls are the actual assistants. Eleanor is obviously carrying a huge load of mental issues, of course. This makes her unauthentic actions a little more authentic, but it is still not enough, in my opinion. Theodora has no reason to act like she is in elementary school. Being playful and childish are two different things. This whole kids playing around vibe also corrupts the story itself, and this is the part where I expect to be ripped apart for what I'm about to say, but I think it was bad writing. Don't get me wrong, it is no mistake that Shirley Jackson is a big name, she has, of course, more than earned her reputation. What I am saying is that this weird atmosphere of unauthentic adults are holding back the actual story, which would otherwise be very good!
The story & the writing I think that the main plot is very interesting, especially the ending and how it can be interpreted in many ways. The very last sentences were worth the whole misery of forcing myself through the book out of love for the series. While it is a little slow, it must not be looked at with a modern eye. One problem I had was that the story was very jumpy. As the book progresses it is becoming more and more filled with very short chapters, which is fine, but as I was reading it I was constantly checking back to see if I had missed something, because it became hectic and chaotic in the plot development and the way the characters are acting didn't help much. I have to say that this book made me feel stupid many times. I'm not used to getting lost in the story of a book, but I have to add again that I liked the story itself, I just don't understand why it was written the way it was. Regarding the writing, I think that it is actually good! But! When it really needs to be good, it's bad, or I should maybe put it this way: the relevant things are very short and underwhelming (but only because of their length!) while the irrelevant/filler parts are lengthy and uncalled for. I feel as if I was starved while being promised to get a very good meal only to find out that the parts of the meal I was looking for the most are purposefully made cold while the side dish is just really nice.
In summary, it is a book that is worth reading, but with low expectations, especially if you love the series as much as I do. The story is nice, but I didn't like many of the characters and the way they are acting in relation with their age and the purpose of their staying in Hill House. I have to say, sadly, that, in my opinion, it did not live up to its reputation.
One last thing I'd like to add is that I am genuinely interested in your comments, because I feel that I just did not understand this book. I did not feel the underlying message that people talk about on reddit. I almost always feel like people are protecting this book's reputation solely because of its reputation. But hey! I am absolutely open to seeing other people's perspectives, especially on the points I criticized.