Trane quotes for whole system replacement: single vs 2stage vs variable AC, Southeast USA
Hi! I'd like to get some opinions on these 5 quotes for a new HVAC (gas and AC) system:
**House info**: \~1800 sq ft, single-story on concrete slab in northeast GA. Home is 22 yrs old and so is the current HVAC system we're replacing. Open floor plan home, ok construction, vinyl siding, sufficient insulation in attic and decent attic ductwork that all techs have told us will work fine for the next 20 yrs. Side rooms on far side of the house are harder to heat and cool, but we installed ceiling fans and our doors are all open much of the time anyway so it's worked ok.
**Current HVAC** is a 3 ton system by Carrier, I think 8 SEER (bless it), with a nat'l gas furnace (no idea what brand). Home uses natural gas for furnace and water heater. All else is electric. **Current energy bills** are around $200 a mo total (coldest winter: $120 gas and $80 electric; highest summer: $20 gas and $180 electric). Spring and fall are nice when both bills fall to $100 total. Local power company says they're raising prices 20% over the next 4 yrs.
**QUOTES**: All quotes are **Trane** because that's the overwhelming option in this area. We did get quotes from a Lennox dealer as well as a 4th installer (trane), but the prices for either aren't any better and I've not liked what I've been reading here and elsewhere about Lennox build quality. The Lennox guy did offer 5 yrs on labor warranty but I have not included his estimates here tho.
Both installers have very good ratings online and have been responsive and good communicators.
Both offer the same **warranties**: 10 yr parts, 10 yr compressor, 20 yr heat exchanger, and either 1 yr labor (for the single-stage systems) or 2 yrs (for the variable).
Both suggest the same coil (4TXC). Neither mentioned heat exchanger model but I can ask.
Both will pour new concrete pad outside, new drain pad, surge protector outdoors, re-use our current linseed. We will also improve the airflow into the air return system and add the proper plenum to the furnace hookup in the attic (we don't have one currently).
​
|Company A. Trane Single|AC: XR14 14 SEER single-stage|S8x2 2 stage furnace|XL824 thermostat|$9,990\*| |:-|:-|:-|:-|:-| |Company B. Trane Single|AC: XR14 14 SEER single-stage|S8x1 1 stage furnace|T6 Honeywell thermostat|$8,550| |Company A. Trane 2-stage|AC: XR16 16 SEER 2-stage|TUD2 2 stage furnace|XL824 therm|$15,469\*| |Company A. Trane Variable AC|AC: XV17 17 SEER variable|S8V2 2 stage furnace |XL824 therm|$14,210| |Company B. Trane Variable AC|AC: XV20i 20Seer variable|S8X1 1 stage furnace |LX850 therm|$12,969|
\*Company A wanted to put in extra air returns in the corner rooms that are harder to heat and cool. We would rather improve air flow through the house. He did take a long time to calculate our home size before quoting. The single and 2-stage quotes for Co.A above do not reflect the lower price we would negotiate to drop the additional air return ducts, maybe it would save a few hundred bucks.
​
​