Got our condenser replaced for $750.
TL;DR at the bottom.
This story starts with our condenser needed to be recharged. During the heat of the summer the AC stopped cooling. We called a local HVAC company, a dad and son operation. They recharged the condenser for $550 (what a deal, but hey it's Florida in the summer), telling us it probably wouldn't last the summer. How little we suspected exactly what that meant.
A month later, I'm in the kitchen getting coffee. I hear a noise outside and the lights flicker as the condenser kicks on and then off. I look outside and hear hissing. I can see a fog hanging close to the ground drifting across the yard coming from the condenser....all the refrigerant leaking out.
Called the HVAC company again. They come out and assess it, say they can replace the whole system for $8200. Wow, what a deal. I ask if they can replace the condenser. They give us the old song and dance about how they can't do it...it's illegal with the new laws. Right.
To our advantage we have a travel trailer with AC and a small window unit used in the master bedroom, so we're not without places to escape the 98F ambient temperatures. We come up with plans to get other quotes. $12,000. $6,800. $8,000. All for full system replacements. No one wants to replace the condenser alone. Some say it's illegal. Others say the parts aren't available any more. We get one guy to give us a quote for a condenser replacement $5,000. It all feels like extortion.
The wife and I begin scheming. We're reading online about the extortionary pricing. We're reading about the 10 year life expectancy of "modern" ac systems and doing the math, don't want to pay what comes out to $1,000 a year for an AC system plus all the extras of recharging, extortionist pricing for servicing and professional advice you absolutely cannot trust. Years ago, my mother was told she needed a complete new system. I checked it myself and found a failed capacitor that cost about $12. That supposedly dead system is now more than 20 years old.
So, we decided we weren't doing it. We were not going to be extorted into paying for a new system because from the manufacturer to the service companies, the entire thing seems like a scam. And the more we thought about it, the more we've become convinced that it is a scam. Especially seeing "used" AC systems on facebook market place for a fraction of the price. We didn't go that route because we couldn't find an HVAC company that would do it and the people that agreed to do it were very sketchy.
Instead we decided to go the window AC & mini-split route. Yeah, it's not pretty. And thank God we don't live in an HOA. We calculated that for $3,500 which included window units, a mini-split and two additional electrical circuits, we could provide cooling for the entire house and I was preparing to set up Home Assistant to control all the units for zoned cooling.
Everything was installed. The house was cool. Two weeks later the company that installed the mini-split called us and said they had a condenser and would install it for $750.
Now we have central AC again. So, for $4,250 we have central AC and redundant cooling. We're still no where near the cost of a new system. We really don't care if that condenser dies in the next year. It's still cheaper than getting a new system. And we know a company now that is willing to provide real service and what the customer wants rather than sell us a song and dance about how they can't fix the system, only replace it.
TL;DR
We spent $3,500 to put in window units and a mini-split instead of going with the $8,000 - $12,000 estimates we were given to replace the entire central air. We were told several times replacing just the part that isn't working - the condenser - is illegal.
The company that installed the mini-split offered us a condenser, installation included for $750 the week after they installed the mini-split. We now have central A/C, window units and a minisplit for $4,200.
* Edit: I didn't realize how emotional this topic would be for some in this thread.