I'm a little mad about how disappointing this flavor is.
I come from stl so I know a bit about a gooey butter cake. It's one of the few things I miss but at least it's an easy recipe to make. I picked this ice cream up from Sprouts in WA after seeing all of the posts about gooey butter cake ice cream and thought I could taste a bit of nostalgia. Not at all the case unfortunately. If you remove the cake pieces, this would actually be a solid burnt caramel ice cream. The texture of the ice cream is pretty solid, and in the other pint I had (yes, I was overly optimistic with how this would be that I bought two) had a really good ribbon of caramel running through it. However, I did question why caramel was added to gooey butter cake. Gooey butter cake is a rather delicate flavor of over sugared wet cheesecake over boxed vanilla cake. Sums up the Midwest perfectly. Caramel would have taken over a lot alone, but it being a slightly burnt caramel overwhelmed any gooey butter notes that may have been present. And those pieces of cake(?) were not at all gooey butter cake. If gooey butter cake were in here, the sugar content would keep it soft and chewy even while frozen. No, these were like frozen Nilla wafers but more hard and chewy like frozen bread. They just interrupted what would have been a fairly enjoyable burnt caramel ice cream.
I give this a solid 2/5, only saved by the base texture if the ice cream being pretty good. If this was labeled "burnt caramel and bread" I'd probably give it 4.5/5.