Oval Help

I’ve narrowed some loose stones down to two slightly elongated ovals. The bottom is a 4.67 ctw that faces up at 4.98 and the top a 4.92 ctw that faces up at 5.47. The IGI reports shows on paper they’re fairly similar so I need help choosing which appears to be superior to the naked eye. I’ve gotten conflicting answers from friends and family so I thought I’d reach out to you guys!