Thoughts on casting in LEC
I have been following League on and off since season 2. Lately I've been zoned out from the scene more than not becuase of life in general, but I usually check in on worlds to see where the scenes at.
This season I got time to watch some games again. Recently I watched the FNC vs BDS game and I was a bit surprised that the casting kind of took me out of the action several times. I feel the casting tone of the original LCS was on par with high level sports leagues and the production value and professonial tone was very good at drawing new viewers and sponsors. If you sent a link to a friend you had to explain the rules of the game etc, but the tone felt like a sports league at the get go.
This game I felt like the casters repeatedly went into water-cooler like banter between colleagues instead of talking about the match, talking about personal conversations, reddit threads and relied heavily on inside jokes about for example sounds of cat farts, breaking out into spontaneous song, referencing jokes in earlier casts or with another colleague etc. To me, the jokes didn't really land since I haven't been keeping up, and it took out a lot of the tension in the game and shifted the focus.
I understand this might be a stylistic or tonal choice, maybe catering to recurring viewers to cultivate a very relaxed personal atmosphere between viewers and casters etc. To me it felt kind of jarring and I was thinking it might raise the threshold for new viewers as well. Since e-sports are often dismissed as not serious or unprofessional in the mainstream I always appreciated League almost erring on the professional side because it became like a gateway e-sport and was very accessible.
Finally, I just want to make clear in that I don't want to attack any individual caster, and I am also open to the possibility that I might not be the target demographic for the product and that's okay with me. I just wanted to hear your thoughts on the matter, and maybe get the perspective from some recurring viewers.
Is the casting more informal now, and what do you think about that?