Is the Tribunal just spamming Punish?
Few days ago I tried out the Tribunal for the first time (had I shitty game with ragers/flamers and I wanted to release so frustration). Anyway, I actually tried to do a good job, I read the whole chatlog provided, I took the scores and attitude of others into consideration and voted Punish or Pardon where I felt it was appropriate.
When I checked the Justice Review however I noticed that my justice rating was under 50% accuracy. I looked at the cases where the community didn't agree with me and it was every single case where I voted 'Pardon'. Every case I voted 'Punish' I was always in line with the community's verdict.
Being the scientifically-minded person that I am, I wanted to subject this to an experiment: I did 15 cases and I voted Punish in every single case, even when I felt Pardon was more appropriate. Not a single disagreement from the community this time. Ofcourse, most players that end up in the Tribunal deserve to be punished but out of 27 cases there hasn't been a single 'Pardon' yet. I know 27 might not be that large of a sample size but still .. Judges on reddit, do you really just spam 'Punish' in the Tribunal?
EDIT: Some guy posted this link in one of the comments:
http://www.reddit.com/r/leagueoflegends/comments/16gjlc/tribunal_statistics/
I think this is pretty interesting and is evidence that there's not that much punish-spamming. However I'm in EUW and I've read several replies where people said EUW punish rates were around 90% which is significantly higher.