RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/massachusetts • … • u/Fortunes_Faded

A Progressive’s Argument Against Q9

With the election coming up next week, I’m going to try and lay out a progressive case for why folks should want to vote **No** on Question 9, including if you generally think that Massachusetts’s gun control legislation should be more restrictive. I’m genuinely happy to talk about this in good faith in the comments, if you’re also willing to talk about this in good faith. Also apologies in advance, this will be long.

I’ll also note off the bat that I know Q9 has opposition from both progressives and conservatives, though the argument against it differs pretty dramatically. I’m not arguing this from the perspective that the Second Amendment is unalienable or any gun control is un-American. This appeal is squarely intended for moderate to progressive voters in Massachusetts who are unsure on Q9 or leaning yes.

So for starters, I think it’s important to talk about the history of gun control in the United States. The Second Amendment had long been a pillar of the various progressive movements throughout our history, as a way of protecting marginalized groups. See John Brown and Beecher’s Bibles all the way through the BPP’s copwatchers in Oakland; Frederick Douglass famously said that “a man’s rights rest in three boxes. The ballot box, jury box and the cartridge box”. Apart from some anti-organized crime legislation coming out of prohibition, the first major piece of gun control legislation in the US was enacted in California in 1967, proposed by a Republican, passed with bipartisan support from both republicans and democrats in the state, and signed into law by Governor Ronald Reagan. This was the Mulford Act, which banned open carry of firearms in the state without a permit. This legislation was specifically designed to stop the Black Panthers, who in response to rampant police brutality in Oakland had taken to forming armed community patrols in Black neighborhoods to watch the Oakland PD and try to prevent foul play.

Cut to today, and we have a much more partisan atmosphere around the second amendment, with the Democratic Party generally supporting more gun control and the Republican Party generally favoring less. Note that this isn’t always the case: in 2025, the federal government tried to target second amendment rights for trans folks, raising concerns across the spectrum that gun control legislation could be weaponized against certain minority groups.

Question 9 specifically has a few significant issues. One is the manner in which it was passed: the large bill was passed extraordinarily quickly, with little debate, and when a petition was raised to hold off until a referendum could be held, the Governor bypassed that using emergency powers, resulting in the weird situation we see today where Q9 requires a No to repeal existing law instead of what it was originally intended to be (ie, a yes or no vote on a proposed law). Another is the concern that this legislation will end up being a poison pill which takes down more of Massachusetts’ prior gun control legislation, as it could be challenged, and make its way up to the Supreme Court, and found unconstitutional (a bit of an aside, though it’s quite fascinating: in June the Supreme Court struck down a gun control law in Hawaii under the Fourteenth Amendment, as its legal justification was rooted in a “black codes” law from Louisiana from just after the civil war designed to give pretext to arrest free Black citizens for laws they didn’t know they were breaking).

Then there are the law enforcement exemptions that the 2024 law introduces. Specifically, it exempts current and former law enforcement officials (state as well as national, so anything from staties to ICE) from the assault weapons restrictions introduced in the law, meaning that privately they can buy things that normal residents can’t. Given the appetite from the federal government to target second amendment rights for groups like the trans community, there is a concern that this law further imperils these groups especially alongside that LEO carve-out.

If by some miracle, the No campaign passes, what happens is this law gets repealed, and then almost certainly the legislature puts up a new bill with a lot of the same content as it had before, minus the LEO carveout and hopefully without a lot of the seemingly intentionally ambiguous verbiage. If the Yes campaign wins, all of these issues persist, and frankly I’d be surprised if an amendment to fix them ever materializes.

A few disclaimers:

\- No, I’m not a bot. I’ve been on Reddit for years, lived in Massachusetts for almost eight years, and have lived in New England all my life. I’m not being paid by any kind of group or PAC, this isn’t some brigading effort, I am an actual human being and these are my actual opinions.

\- No, I’m not a secret Republican. I have literally never voted for a Republican candidate in my life. I volunteered for and donated to Sanders in ‘16 and ‘20, then again for the Democratic nominee in each general presidential election through ‘24.

\- Yes, I’m (now) a gun owner, as of last year: after the new law was passed. Yes, I think that many of Massachusetts’ existing (pre-2024) gun legislation is valuable, though otherwise I’ve been a proponent of the second amendment my entire life, having grown up in northern New England where firearm ownership is far more common. Like any rational person, I despise the NRA.

If you read all this, thanks. If you didn’t, fair enough. Either way (and however you receive this) **please** vote on November 3rd!

— 0