RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/metroidvania • … • u/Otherwise_Sun8521

Quit Silk Song Because It's Boring Not Because it's hard

First Lets get this out of the way. I’m not interested in a debate about Silk Songs “objective” quality: the game is fine and if you like it more power to you.  This is mostly an opportunity to vent, commiserate with other people who didn’t click with the game and to give a well reasoned diatribe on why some people based on game design preference and skill level will simply not be better served by pushing through until it “clicks”.  Also, yes, difficulty does technically play a role in why I didn’t enjoy it, and yes, I’m very well aware the game isn’t for me.  These are not gotch ya facts that completely invalidate my criticisms.

Reasons why I found silk song boring

Story/world: I have very little patience/respect for “stories” that are carried by lore, respecting your audiences intelligence to read between the lines is admirable, but if the vast majority of the whos and whys of the central conflict and character progression of your game is buried in optional NPC interactions and bestiary’s or is expressed through the extremely vague and open to interpretation nature of level design and gameplay: I’m gonna stop caring real quick.  I know this method of world building is more or less par the course for soulslikes (and frankly I play very few games for the story) but seeing as this is considered a massive step up in storytelling from Hollow knight and something as basic as making Hornet talk very occasionally is apparently enough to make it a “master piece” I felt inclined to be more critical of the “story telling”. For silk song I made it as far as clockwork dancers and there has been barely a paragraph of narrative progression. I was kidnapped, reasonably intuited these people would be a nuisance if I didn’t solve the root of the problem and proceeded to beat up a bunch of dudes on the way to the citadel.  Nothing I personally consider to be meaningful has happened, I genuinely don’t have any more reason narratively to see this through than I did at the beginning and knowing the rough outline of how act 3 plays out from youtube I’m in no hurry to experience that story.

Mechanics:

Hollow knight combat is basic and under developed.  The gamefeel of the platforming and the singular melle weapon are admittedly very good, but the perry is virtually meaningless offering only damage mitigation and staggering the enemy is too beholden to the developers strict pacing to feel like a fleshed out or varied case of risk reward management.  Hornet has a slightly greater than average variety of movement ability’s but most of it is things I’ve seen in other metroidvanias and none of it is so well executed I’d say its particularly special for gamefeel alone.  Meanwhile the insinuation tends to be that Hornet is so mobile that she doesn’t need I frames or a more traditional blocking mechanism, but the number of bosses that zoom around the battle field at speeds faster than hornet can for free (especially in the air) or have massive wide sweeping attacks that essentially force you to stand still or cautiously walk in time to \*their\* rhythm leaves me entirely disagreeing with that sentiment.

\>!The Claw line in particular is incredibly frustrating because I both love it and hate it.  As a pure combat tool it does somewhat mitigate my complaints about hornets lack of mobility and is fairly satisfying to land, but the fact that it’s limited by silk makes it especially frustrating to whiff, which happens far too often with how narrow the hitbox for the needle is. Furthermore it’s down right atrocious as a traversal mechanic, because again the nail has a tiny hitbox for the grapple rings and the fact that hornet has no good way of recovery from a missed clawline for a significant portion of the game, reduces it to a trashy hookshot variant the devs are forcing you to use for some of the most tedious and otherwise forgettable hookshot courses I’ve ever had to slog through.  The fact that the devs had to throw the bandaid of regenerating 1 silk from zero should’ve been a clear indicator that something was wrong but nope: this is fine!<

Moving on after two games of this: I officially do not like the Spirit/Silk system.  In order for it to be a fun engaging system that adds legitimate gameplay variety it’d need at minimum the option to equip two different kinds of heals at a time and have those heals run on a spectrum from twice as fast as base speed for less silk healing one mask to twice as long as base speed while having armor/increased recovery/casting stat buffs/cast offensive spell while healing.  As it is I’m not making interesting decisions during a boss fight or while exploring, and the decisions I make while making a build are extremely simple and straightforward.  All it really accomplishes is to severely restrict the pacing and frequency at which the player can heal or perform high damaging attacks, while also punishing them for not following the precise borderline scripted experience that is a boss fight.

Then there are the silk skills themselves and the tools none of which are amazing gameplay recontextualizing mechanics: they’re badly implemented one button specials!  They have barely any gamefeel, they’re highly situational, their reliance on meter or ammo capacity means they’re just another tool for the devs to force you to play to their rhythm and if playing on gamepad they have an annoying overlap where it’s very easy to use up said precious resources on the wrong action.

Which all culminates in bosses that are far too tanky.  IN MY OPINION a character truly built around speed and mobility should be the one setting the pace of the fight, such that while yes the bosses can hit harder, tank more hits and may have some massive hurt boxes, they also should have WEAKNESSES that allow a player who is actually on hornets implied level to obliterate the boss in seconds.  >!As it is, even if the player uses absolutely ALL upgrades available in act 1, AFTER spamming ALL poison tacks and with all the nail upgrades you can get: the last judge requires you to land 40 separate hits!!<  For comparison that’s like fighting Margit with an un upgraded club in Eldin Ring, only ten hits better than fighting the Mantis Lords with an un upgraded nail in Hollow Knight and worse than fighting the abyss watchers with an un upgraded club in Dark Souls 3!

Finally Act 2 is underwhelming.  One of the reasons why I bothered to play a game I knew I would have very luke warm feelings about, is because basically all the fans were talking up act 2 as some amazing experience where all the cool toys and fun set pieces are while also becoming significantly easier.  This is drastically overselling how open, rewarding or easy act 2 is and even with the clockwork dancers fight, it was simply not worth the time I spent to reach it.  >!Beating Last judge doesn’t suddenly shower you in nail upgrades, extra masks and tool upgrades: it locks the player in a sewer full of benches you have to \*pay for\* and tight claustrophobic platforming. When you make it out you gain access to debatably the most generic uninteresting locations in the game and once you have access to fast travel again you can go through a LOT of work and exploration to EVENTUALLY get all those upgrades that allegedly make things easier in act 2, which they really don’t.!< Personally, it was too little too late as by the time I had those upgrades I’d killed all the things that would’ve been “easy” with said upgrades and all that was left were a bunch of tedious slogs I still had no way to make fun or even reasonable to fight.   The handful of new areas weren’t worth the effort and what I’ve seen of act 3 doesn’t look remotely fun or interesting mechanically/aesthetically enough to justify the amount of banging my head against a wall I would have to do to get it.

— 0