RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/minnesotavikings • … • u/Clear_Moose5782

3 Bad, 3 Good, One question

Three bad things

1. JJM in the first 57 minutes was bad. No need to belabor this point.

2. JJM didn't get a lot of help from his team mates. 5 drops on 32 targets is horrendous - about 3 over expectation. And this wasn't new this week. Addison and Jefferson have both dropped more balls than we have grown to expect. Now some of the drops may be because JJ is throwing the ball with too much velocity. But Jets, Addison, Hockenson, and Jones are all premium pass catchers at their position - and three of them are being paid very well. They need to clean this up.

3. Special teams. Matt Daniels needs to go. Losing contain on the kick off return contributed to the loss. We seem to have a big run back called back due to a penalty every week or so. Either fire Daniels or start cutting some of these fringe roster guys if only to send a message. I don't agree with people who said we should have kicked it out of the endzone. There was a minute left, Chicago had all three time outs, and would only need to "drive" 25 yards to be in field goal range. Do you have confidence the D could have stopped Williams operating in four down territory under those circumstances? I don't.

Three good things:

1. JJ in the last three minutes was good. A QB who is capable of forgetting 57 minutes of bad play (while hearing the first boos he's ever had directed at him from his home crowd in his life), and go out and lead a go ahead drive, is a QB who has something there. Now, he absolutely needs to be better in those first 57 minutes, but every great QB has bad games, and one who shows he can over come them when it matters is one giving you a something to hold on to. he needs to demonstrate he can effectively run the offense consistently as you can't make it as a starting QB on "heart" and "moxie" alone, but at least having those is something.

2. The D was very solid. They mostly contained Williams in the pocket and he didn't make any of the crazy plays he made in the previous three games. He did let him slip out of a couple of sacks, but as a whole they did well.

3. Pass protection was excellent. The OL had a lot of issues to start the season, but has gotten much better the past two weeks, mainly because they are now mostly healthy.

**A couple of bonus good things** \- because we need a bit more positivity:

A. KOC going to a more run heavy scheme shows that he is at least a bit able to adapt to his circumstances.

B. Dallas Turner had his best game as a pro.

C. And while we can't make our candle burn brighter by blowing someone else's out, Darnold going out in his biggest game of this season and throwing 4 INTs clearly demonstrated moving on from him was a very reasonable course of action. Now, I have no doubt that had we kept him, we'd be 6-4 or 7-3 (or better) as we've lost 3 or 4 very winnable games (even if we didn't deserve to win them). But if the QB is going to fold in the biggest games, there isn't any reason to bother with him. The only thing that matters is winning a Super Bowl.

**A question I have:** We keep seeing/hearing that McCarthy's issues with accuracy are "mechanical". But....he had NFL level coaching at Michigan, and he's had a QB coach since he was in high school. And of course we hear that his is a "football psycho" who works his ass off to get better. So, why does he have substantive mechanical issues at this point? To be clear - I'm not saying he does or doesn't. Like most of you I have no idea. It just seems to me that there is a disconnect between what we have heard about him as a guy, what his background is in football, and what we are seeing on the field. So either the coaches are fixing something that isn't broken; lying to cover up other issues; or he isn't the product we have been told.

— 0