RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/mrgirlreturns • … • u/Incense

How and why MrGirl's latest series of substack posts are bullshit

[Context, MrG's On Human Extinction and the Bodily Autonomy of Women](https://mrgirl.substack.com/p/on-human-extinction-and-the-bodily)

#Definitional games and falling into tropes

This is a really almost identical framing-of-events and rhetorical tricks & manipulation that white supremacists will levy upon the casual reader. When a white supremacists defines "white genocide" as interracial marriage and not birthing new white babies, it's true in the way they frame it. Less white babies means less white people in the future, and all studies predict that the future is "Brown".

When a reader not savvy with the rhetorical tricks, you are kind of pulled into the rhetorical hamster wheel if you engage, even when the sensible person says "yeah white genocide, so what?" then that proclives that white people ought to defend themselves since you are pro genocide.

• You want white people to die out.

• You are the enemy of white people (even if you're 'white').

• You are a genocide supporter

The definition frames reality and synthesizes language in a way that makes sense in the sentence but doesn't fully map to reality. There's no white race, it's a social construct with its main drive being to maintain a social hierarchy.

-------------------------

How does talking about white supremacy relate to Mrgirl's string of posts about this? Just like a white supremacist builds the hamster wheel with language, MRgirl uses progressivism and feminism to set you into a trap. He verbalized it, just here in the article you read:

• You are pro rape

• You are not a true progressive

• You do not respect consent

Unless you agree with his definition of coercion. Here's why his definition of coercion is nothing short of myopic:

If you ask a woman out on a date, you hit it off in some kind of really gay (dating women can be more gay than dating men sometimes), Hollywood type of way and then have consensual sex is that rape?

According to Mrgirl's definition, you would be coercing her with the concept of a "hitting it off" ubiquitous in media and subsequent inter personal narratives, all that would be needed here is a 'flow' to coerce a woman through the subtle idealization of the perfect but — unbeknownst to both you — emotionally sterile date.

You would be raping her more than you are not-raping her, in the rape metric. If you go on a date with women and you're chivalrous and attentive, you are pseudo raping them.

--------------------------------------------

# On the analogy of this essay:

There's a game of definitions being played here. The word Coercion is stretched. The word consent is stretched, the terminology of "forcing women to have babies" (Rape and cognitively forceful insemination) is stretched and now this weird spaghettification of words is molded to have a pointy end, aimed at you, the non rapist reader:

If you don't engage with the essay as the author wants, you are evading the hypothetical. If you don't want humanity to die out in this scenario, you are not a true progressive, not a true feminist, you'd be in the same alley that rapist hide in to ambush their victims. This essay's words and meanings are undone and then recombined for a myriad of the inner workings of the author that — while not malignant (?) — is honestly just an intellectual jungle gym, full of ropes, trampolines, & fun incentives and activities to make you fall in line with how the author puts the straw in words, sucks the meaning out, and puts another filling in.

The hypothetical is fucking stupid on its face, stupid on its definitions, just as the conversation of a white genocide or the semantical game migrant invader.

If a white supremacists tries to rope you into the definition of a white genocide, you have to be sharper than him and not engage, lest you risk being put in the rhethorical hamster ball. When MrGirl tells you you are a rapist unless you want humanity to die out, you lose just by engaging in his definition.

MrGirl said in the past when put in a similar rhetorical trap he's now trying to entrap you in:

"I reject your framing."

It's time you consider rejecting his. If you respect his work, or like his work, not for how it makes you feel or how attached you are to the figure rather than his message, you should demand less of this misplaced deconstructionism.

---

The subtext of this substack is putting the onus on men to decide for women, as if men are not also cognitively coerced by the shared narrative of the continued species. Though of course, the author of this substack would argue that female cognitive autonomy takes priority because their bodies are at stake, pregnancy is an invasive process (according to progressive and certain feminist schools of thought, yet another framing this substack is opering within.)

There's a seemingly endless, inward spiral of recombined definitions and that this substack is operating in which sets you the reader into an interesting question:

If MrGirl defines your ambivalence as evading the hypothetical, adopting abstract idealism as being unambiguously pro rape, your disagreement with him as being stupid and him smart, would you be all of these things as he defines it, letting the parasite suck your brain from the inside out with a straw and replace it with a liquefied something-else, or would you reject his framing?

— 0