Directly Compaing the Body Horror of the Alabaster Host from New Phyrexia and All Will Be One
It's the common opinion that between New Phyrexia and All Will Be One, the design and body horror of the phyrexian was significantly toned down. While we know this is intentional i feel like lots of people exagerate it (driven by negativity bias combined with nostalgia) and ignore the different directions the design moved towards, which i think are still very much worthwhile.
The W faction has always been the most iconic of New Phyrexia, especially thanks to [Elesh Norn](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/9/elesh-norn-grand-cenobite)'s og art that combined horror and regality in an art with powerful color contrast. This design language was a one-of in New Phyrexia but was used as the faction's visual identity in ONE.
To talk more about Elesh Norn, she look otherworldy and unreachable while also fragile (being made of bone-like porcelain and exposed guts) she gives a power feel of "tained holiness" due to the red on the white. Sensor Splicer also plays in the same space, even if in a much less effective way, there is no "holiness" to be tained due to the more mundane context and the weaker light weakens the contrast, making it look like some weird zombie artificer i guess.
A recurring design of the W faction is present in [Channelor of the Annex](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/6/chancellor-of-the-annex), [Shattered Angel](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/23/shattered-angel) and [Lost Leonin](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/13/lost-leonin). They are all characterize by the shreds of dead flash hanging from their bodies, Channelor and Shattered play into the juxtaposition of holy and unholy, with Channelor also sharing some visual language with Elesh Norn and Shattered Angel putting emphasis on the animal-like pose and the massive mouth filled with teeths. Lost Leonin once again imo falls shorts due to losing its holiness, focusing more an the animal-like exposed skull. The art is still decently effective, but imo it gets quickly reduced to "cool zombie" when you see that most of the "shreds of its body" are just what remains of a cape.
[Phyrexian Unlife](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/18/phyrexian-unlife) is to me the 2nd most iconic art from the set. It does not play in body horro but in psychological horror. The eyes are filled with desperation behind a perfect and emotionless mask, the hands trying to understand the new form that was imposed on them. Another art that uses contrast in a fantastic way, amking the eyes pop out in what looks like an empty void, impossible to look away from.
[Suture Priest](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/25/suture-priest) is an interesting case, the bleeding eyes are certainly effective and certainly the most iconic part of the card but, once again, the low light once again fails the body horro as the muscle of the priest appear way too dark, like they're black leather. Making them look like a mage in a weird armor. The long, spike-like fingers help mitigate this feeling a bit tho, combined with the unsual armor and the serene/neutral expression it makes it look otherwordly and alien.
Some other cards don't attempt body horror at all: [Apostle's Blessing](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/2/apostles-blessing) and [Loxodon Convert](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/14/loxodon-convert) are just dudes in armor while [Shriek Raptor](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/24/shriek-raptor) is a very bog-standard bone bird. [Porcelain Legionnair](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/19/porcelain-legionnaire) is just a robot. [Master](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/16/master-splicer) and [Blade Splicer](https://scryfall.com/card/nph/4/blade-splicer) are spiny? They do look good but at most the horror comes from them being monsters that can gauge your eyes off. Not very unique to Phyrexia.
Now to talk about All Will Be One.
The first point of comparison is absolutely Elesh Norn. In her [standard art](https://scryfall.com/card/one/10/elesh-norn-mother-of-machines) the focus is pulled away from her to show her immense throne made of petrified phyrexians. This is an effective visual to show the depersonalization that defines the flavor of the faction. Beyond that, tho, the design of Elesh Norn loses a lot of bite here. Gone is the contrast between the bright red of her drapes and the darker red of her flesh, now they look one and the same. The addition of other figures to the art also makes Norn look shorter, removing a lot of her imposing and alien energy. It still effectively plays into the holiness of the figure, but everything else is a big step down. There are two showcase arts to look at: [the first](https://scryfall.com/card/one/345/elesh-norn-mother-of-machines), made by Pedro Potier goes back to be closer to her original design, even tho, due to the lack of color, there is no contrast to be had. The cracks on her head and armor are more evident than in any other art and make it feel like organic bone rather than inorganic porcelain, which i think is a nice take. The main problem with the art is the framing tho, the textbox starts right above her hips, making it much harder to understand her tall and slander figure, here Norn doesn't really feel imposing and unreachable, like she should. The [second showcase art](https://scryfall.com/card/one/298/elesh-norn-mother-of-machines), done by Dominik Mayer imo is a massive step up. Here she finally feels tall, slender and superior, the big black and white lines smudged by the oil around her feel like they're spinning with her at the center. Even with only black and white Mayer plays a lot with contrast, her body once again feels tainted, biological but alien, untouchable yet fragile, powerful and yet exposed. The lack of precise contours makes it look like she's growing out of the oil itself.
Now, I'll have to make an exception as I'l ltalk not about ONE but about the [Phyrexian Unlife](https://scryfall.com/card/sld/1213/phyrexian-unlife) that was released as a SLD with ONE, still by Mayer. If the og Unlife was about a quiet, muted horro and desperation, this one is the opposite. With very simple shapes Mayer is able to evoke violent panic, the art feels asphyxiating, the long diagonal lines feel like movement, a visceral movement in search of freedom from the mask, once again the borders are smudged and incomplete, everything blends together, making it feel like you are losing touch with the outside world.
As i said before, a few cards on this faction show phyrexian turned into stones. [Ossification](https://scryfall.com/card/one/26/ossification) is nothing to write home about. They just look like statues and that's it. On the other hand [Veil of Assimilation](https://scryfall.com/card/one/37/veil-of-assimilation) feels much more powerful. It's a clear rift on the og Phyrexian Unlife with the main difference on not putting desperate human-like eyes as the focus, but the lack of mouth of the mask. I initially didn't thought much of it, but the more i look at it the more constricting it feels, an interesting combination of the quiet doom of Chan's Unlife and the claustrophobia of Mayer's.
Also as i said before, Elesh Norn's design language of red on white was extend to most of the faction, with varying degrees of success. Starting with the least effective, where what should be guts and muscle on bone and porcelain just feel like red silk on white armor. [Bladed Ambasciator](https://scryfall.com/card/one/5/bladed-ambassador), [Jawbone Duelist](https://scryfall.com/card/one/18/jawbone-duelist), [Orthodoxy Enforcer](https://scryfall.com/card/one/25/orthodoxy-enforcer), [Porcelain Zealot](https://scryfall.com/card/one/30/porcelain-zealot) and [Phyrexian Vindicator](https://scryfall.com/card/one/27/phyrexian-vindicator) all fall in this category, i also think this is what a lot of people think of when they talk about the new art of new phyrexia, as they quite obviously stick out in a very negative way and our brain are evolutionary predisposed to remember the negative things better. They all fail imo by making no effort to make the muscle actually look like muscle, it has no real trace of biologu, just texture that passes way too easly for clothes. Some of them have drapes that are made of supposed muscles, the horro should come by the fact that muscles are used like capes and mantles, but the effect is just the opposite, removing any horror.
Now to talk about those that execute the same aesthetic much, much better. [Annex Sentry](https://scryfall.com/card/one/2/annex-sentry) works mostly due to the tendons? that keep its head up and the very clear difference in texture between muscles and drapes. The biology feels present yet alien, the small head, barely held up by just a few strings of muscles is just unnerving. [Crawling Chorus](https://scryfall.com/card/one/8/crawling-chorus) feels similarly unnerving, it's body shape doesn't look biological at all and we can clearly see how it looks like it was made by sewing together bands of muscles, forcing them in a perfect geometric shape. The idea of muscles forced in a certain shapes that contracts and relaxes, that pulses like an heart is pretty fucked up to me. The multiple faces are also a clear source of horror, maybe playing with the implication that the Chorus is combination of different beings. To me this is very reminescent of the body horror of All Tomorrows, for anyone who is aware. [Zaelot's Conviction](https://scryfall.com/card/one/39/zealots-conviction) clearly feels like muscle, you can feel how powerful the phyrexian is and how all that flesh would contract right before it strikes. It plays in a design that few other arts play in: the stained bone, to me the smudges of red on the yellowing white really make it feel real, making it feel gross and horrifying. [Sinew Dancer](https://scryfall.com/card/one/32/sinew-dancer) is kinda of an inbetween case. The body itself doesn't feel to organic but the net? dripping with fluid sure does. [Basicila Shepard](https://scryfall.com/card/one/4/basilica-shepherd) goes back into the "tained angel" style, the body is completely red and it's hard to note texture, but the wings, oh those wings. They feel fragile and sharp, the very irregular separation between the white and the red makes them feel like the bone has been naturally growing and it still hasn't stopped; also, the drape, here finally the horrorific double visual works! It's not a uniform red texture, it's made of darker fibers, it's so clearly not stiched together, this also feels like it has just grown on its own, just thing layer of muscle continuing to grow outside the body itself.
An element that a few art share is that of the "blood cloud": [Apostle of Invasion](https://scryfall.com/card/one/3/apostle-of-invasion), [Duelist of Deep Faith](https://scryfall.com/card/one/9/duelist-of-deep-faith) and [Flensing Raptor](https://scryfall.com/card/one/12/flensing-raptor) use it. This adds so much biology to the art, the cloud of blood implies that there actually is blood flowing in those muscle and guts and that that blood is spilling out as they breath and move. Apostle's wings especially feels indefinite, like they were made by thousands of interwoven capillaries that were not completely closed off and so just tiny, tiny drops spill out; Apostle also does a good job with the drape/guts, clearly showing how its growing from under its armor. The lack of eyes and hands also heightens the horror quite a bit, the creature just feels so helpless.
[Indoctrination Attendant](https://scryfall.com/card/one/16/indoctrination-attendant) combines effectively lots of the positive traits that i listed so far: the alien body shape, the textured flesh, the yellowed bone, the believable biology and the low cloud of blood. It all combines in just an unnerving picture.
A new design elements that was added in ONE was teethes, 3 art in particular focus on it, I'll talk about them in order of how repulsed they make me feel. [Mandible Justicer ](https://scryfall.com/card/one/21/mandible-justiciar)it's the tames, and this is saying a lot. First, the exoskeleton and the featurless, mouthless head is really cool, it having a phyrexian writing instead of any eyes or sensory organs makes it quite fucked. The main piece are the arms tho, they are turned into long mandibles that finish with an hand each. It's such an unique design and due to the "mouth" being closed, it makes you imagine how they would look like if open, addid to the horror. [Swooping Lookout](https://scryfall.com/card/one/35/swooping-lookout): no face, 3 arms, 2 mouth-wings, another 2 pairs of wings with a row of teeth each that don't look like they can close and another horn mouth? im not even sure about it. This creature looks so fucked. Perfectly alien, the red of the gums and of the cracks of the bone make it feel very organic. Fantastic fucked body horror that actively goes against our understanding of biology. [Incisor Glider](https://scryfall.com/card/one/15/incisor-glider): i hate this. I HATE THIS SO MUCH. I don't want to look at it. That art gives me a visceral feeling of disgust and of fight or flight that no other art in mtg ever did. It looks like a paper airplane made of flesh and bone that was then covered in teeth. It makes no biological sense and yet it's made of clearly organic material. It looks like a mockery of biological life. It looks like an object that was grown from a human-like being, bending its biology into a pure perversion of life without being able to completely contain it. Those teeth just feel so wrong.