RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/nbadiscussion • … • u/Mr_Saxobeat94

How much value, if any, did Wilt bleed by not consistently playing team basketball?

Bit of a niche topic but I thought I’d ask for input on this corner of the internet.

Full disclosure: Wilt was my GOAT for the longest time. I was a kid obsessed with Bill James/Sabermetrics (for which metrics like Win Shares or WAR are more easily applied to a linear sport of discrete events like baseball…for basketball, box score happenings simply aren’t enough, as pbp/hybrid advanced metrics are way more win-predictive). As a result, box scores sometimes unduly informed my opinion on old-time hoopers I didn’t watch, and so the first time I read up on Wilt’s exploits…I was almost dumbfounded that anyone else could even be *entertained* as his equal. He seemed peerless.

Ffwd to today…he is the inner-circle great I’ve done the biggest about-face on. Not the most damning criticism given the “inner-circle great” qualifier, as I still have him in the 9-12 range…but, in addition to being a genuinely great player, he was also a genuinely brazen stat-padder. Not in the way LeBron haters accuse their boogeyman of being. No, Wilt very openly chased statistical crowns at the expense of team results. Even with that, I think he had a GOAT-level one-year peak ('67, when his optimal style of play was unlocked; didn't last long, as he became obsessed with leading the league in assists the following year) and GOAT-level skills (particularly relative to the era he was in, where big-men were roughly as important in basketball as QB’s are now in football)…but he was, IMO, far too wishy-washy to compare the four players I think have the best claim to being the GOAT: Jordan, LeBron, Kareem, and Russell.

This entry, from Ben Taylor (“Thinking Basketball”) puts it about as well as anyone has:

[ https://thinkingbasketball.net/2017/12/04/backpicks-goat-9-wilt-chamberlain/ ](https://thinkingbasketball.net/2017/12/04/backpicks-goat-9-wilt-chamberlain/)

One of the takeaways I’ve come to after re-examining some old film, contextualizing the #’s, parroting the words of much smarter people and reading contemporary accounts, is that his raw box score statistics likely overrated his impact. Especially his scoring, which towered over everyone else in his era in large part because:

a) team offences were more egalitarian, individual stars simply didn’t shoot as much on a per-possession basis back then.

yet

b) there were many, many more possessions in an average game. So, even with these less heliocentric team offences, individual stars still put up per-game averages not too dissimilar from (and sometimes well clear of) the stars of today.

Those two factors combined to make Wilt's (admittedly still very impressive) scoring numbers seem more prodigious than they actually were, because Wilt played a uniquely heliocentric game relative to his peers, but (like all of them) his team burned through more possessions than the average team of today. So, how much does re-contextualizing blunt him? Simply put: **Even his best scoring year, '62, doesn't rank in the Top 25 of all-time per-possession scoring seasons.**

Here's a long excerpt from the “Impact Evaluation” section of the link I cited:

*In Thinking Basketball, Wilt is the case study for Global Offense. He produced unrivaled individual scoring numbers, but they didn’t move the needle much for his team. It’s only when his game shifted away from volume-scoring that his team’s offenses flourished. He’s perhaps the ultimate illustration that individual offense does not automatically equate to successful team offense.*

*There’s a massive negative correlation (-0.76) between Wilt’s scoring attempts and his team’s offensive rating. So, the less Wilt shot, the better and better his team’s offenses performed. I won’t rehash what’s outlined in detail in the book, but needless to say, Wilt’s skill set described in the scouting report contributed to this phenomenon; not creating for teammates is extremely limiting.*

*Most volume scorers will taper down on good offenses, but Wilt is unique in that he completely shifts his style of play away from scoring on all of his successful offensive clubs. In some ways, Wilt was the original “Black Hole” – when the ball went in to him, it wasn’t coming out.*

*To put this into perspective, we can look at his ratio of true shot attempts (TSA) to assists.4Historically, Jordan’s ’87 scoring spree comes in at 7.2:1 and Kobe’s ’06 barrage at 7.0:1. Those are the two highest scoring seasons per possession in NBA history. Wilt’s ’61 and ’62 seasons had ratios just under 20:1, good for sixth and seventh all-time, behind such legendary offensive forces as Howard Porter (1974) and Charlie Villenueva (2015). Even 1982 Moses Malone was around 15:1, and his favorite pass was off the backboard to himself. Here are Wilt’s outlier seasons visually:*

*So we know that early Chamberlain shot the ball a lot, didn’t create much, and (predictably) his team’s offenses weren’t very good. Can we infer how much he was actually moving the needle for those teams?*

*When Wilt joined the Warriors in 1960, the offense improved by about a single point per 100 possessions.5 That offense was still 2.4 points below league average (relative offensive rating, or rORtg), the first major signal that Wilt’s volume scoring didn’t automatically equate to great offense.*

*This was inline with his lack of creation; Chamberlain scored at 21.5 points per 75 possessions that year on efficiency 3.0 percent better than league average (relative True Shooting, or rTS). For comparison, 2017 Kevin Love was 22.7 at +2.0 percent. It would counter every trend in NBA history for this kind of isolation scoring or finishing (from offensive rebounds or off-ball scoring) to automatically generate quality team offense. If we plug in turnovers for Wilt — from low percentage to high percentage — his averages during those volume scoring years were 24 points per 75, +5.0 percent rTS and about a 3 percent creation rate (3 shots created per 100), closest historically to 1981 Robert Parish, 2007 Carlos Boozer, 1981 Moses Malone and 1996 Alonzo Mourning.*

\_

All of that said, there’s only so much a single player can do, even in basketball…but a GOAT-level offensive player should not be presiding over such mediocre offences barring some truly extreme circumstances. The before-and-after’s of some of his team’s speak volumes. One oft-repeated claim is that Russell had far greater teammates and better teams. This was true *on the whole*, because the two halves of Wilt’s career came with markedly different qualities of supporting casts…but not in the back half of Wilt's career.

From ‘65 to ‘72, Wilt’s supporting casts were every bit as good as Russell’s ever were, minus the team cohesion cultivated over years of chemistry-building and continuity (enabled by great leadership from Russell!) Take the Lakers team he inherited. The ‘68 Lakers won 52 games, had the #1 offence in the league, and lost in the finals. Wilt joined a near-identical team...they promptly had 3.2 Ortg points shaved off, “only” won 55 and failed to win the title. Meanwhile, the Sixers won 55 w/o him, despite a devastating injury to one of their best big men, Luke Jackson.

The next year '69-'70, with Wilt sidelined, the Lakers won 46. The year after he retired they won 47, despite West only suiting up for 31 contests and retiring as well. All of this is not to say that he didn’t tremendously impact those Lakers and Sixers squads; he abso did. But these were fantastic supporting casts. If Russell's 11 in 13 are diminished due to his supposedly obscene amount of help, Wilt shouldn't get a pass for "only" winning 2 over the last 7 years of his career. Especially since his Sixers/Lakers had HCA 3x against an older Russell, were favoured each time, and yet “only” won once, in the year Russell started juggling player-coach responsibilities and was making notable substitution gaffes.

To give a sense of how much “HOF tallying” overrated Russell’s underlings: the ‘69-‘70 Celtics (in their first year without Russell) boasted **five** Hall of Famers in their rotation…average age? 28. They went from winning the title to missing the postseason, with this crew overseeing one of the largest single-season drtg drop-off’s in league history (89.1 to 98.9). It was common in those days for even middling teams to employ 3-4 future HOF’ers, that was sort of the nature of the smaller, more concentrated league back then. Even Wilt typically had 3-4 HOF teammates in his early years, on those sorry squads. Never mind that several of Russell’s HOF teammates rode into the hall on his coattails.

So, what do you guys think? Am I over-correcting for being a Wilt Zealot? And where do you stand on his ability to impact winning?

— 0