RedditPP Mascot

RedditPP

r/onednd • … • u/rpg2Tface

Unarmed strikes

I feel like the concept of an unarmed strike is a little wierd. It’s a method of dealing damage for martials that ISNT a weapon, but it has a very simple profile.

So thinking of this my idea is to stat out an unarmed strike as a simple weapon with a D1 damage and no other properties.

Doing this has some interesting interactions. First being a D1 instead of a flat 1 allows paladins to smite with their fists.

Second the classes that can properly throw a punch becomes more realistic. All the book nerd wizards can’t punch effectively, but since most of the classes get simple weapon proficiency their mostly uneffected.

Third you can technically duel wield with a feat. Useful for non monk unarmed users, but monks have it built in as a monk weapon now.

Forth, being a “weapon” with a stat line and everything it’s far easier to mod. Like monks now actually giving the weapon the finease property. This has quite a few more uses but that’s the big one for me.

The one thing I don’t like about this change is it interferes with the new grapple/ shove changes. You could add the special property to them and get it in that way but it’s also messes with monk when you try to.

It would require a lot of reshuffling to get things back right again but it can be done, the effort could make it prohibitively complicated for WOTC to try to do but that’s just my option.

So what’s the general opinion on this idea. Since their changing how they word the non weapon attack options I think a change for unarmed strikes could help smith some things and make them easier to understand instead of being that one worked attack in the corner.

— 0